Breaking News
Local Sports

YSU, Cincy clash a battle between mentor, mentee

YSU, Cincy prepare for clash

By NEEL MADHAVAN 7 min read
Correspondent file photo / Robert Hayes Youngstown State coach Ethan Faulkner on the sidelines during a game in 2024.

When Ethan Faulkner takes his Youngstown State squad across the state to Cincinnati on Wednesday night, it'll be a full-circle moment for both the program and the Penguins' head coach.

Awaiting YSU on the opposing bench for the Bearcats at Fifth Third Arena will be a familiar face in former head coach Jerrod Calhoun, who spent seven years leading Penguins and helped turn around what was once a floundering program and a bottom dweller in the Horizon League.

"He's going to try to beat us by 30, and we're going to try to go down there and win the game," Faulkner said during his press conference on Monday. "We're going to try to play to the best of our ability. Obviously, I've got so much respect for him. I think he is an elite basketball coach. I think he's one of the best coaches in the country. My job is to make sure our team is prepared to go give ourselves a chance to have some success."

For Faulkner, it'll be the first time he goes head-to-head against his mentor and former boss since Calhoun brought him on YSU's coaching staff from the University of the Cumberlands, an NAIA school, in 2019.

"He's the biggest mentor I've got in this profession," Faulkner said. "I talk to him all the time. I wouldn't be sitting in this chair without him. One of my closest friends in the world. I learned so much from him by working with him."

In the past, Calhoun has coached against his own mentors. For example, when he was at Fairmont State (W.Va.) and YSU, he went against Bob Huggins' West Virginia teams multiple times. But, it'll be his first time coaching against one of his former assistants.

"It's probably not going to be great because those are my friends. But for those 40 minutes, you gotta coach your team," Calhoun said in a phone interview on Monday. "I've never done this, so it'll be a first-time experience for me."

Back when Faulkner joined Calhoun's staff, YSU was still recovering from an era of turmoil and timidity.

The program only had two winning records in the previous 18 seasons and Calhoun was headed into his third year of trying to turn things around in Youngstown.

"When he got here, I think there were a lot of things that he felt needed to be improved," Faulkner said. "For me, I wasn't here through the struggle, the first two years getting it back off the ground. Obviously I know the stories about what that was like, but I wasn't here to experience that."

During that season, the first positive signs of Calhoun's revival project started to emerge. YSU went 18-15 that year, its first winning season since 2012-13.

From there, Calhoun led the Penguins to five straight winning seasons and the program's first regular season Horizon League championship in 2022-23.

"From there, once we started to have success, the momentum just started to build," Faulkner said. "We started signing some really good players and became a much more attractive place to be in terms of recruiting. The job that [Calhoun] did here is remarkable."

After a seven-year run, Calhoun left Youngstown for Utah State after the 2023-24 season and Faulkner was elevated to head coach shortly thereafter.

"We did so much at Youngstown. Not just from a win-loss standpoint, but helped renovate the locker room, helped renovate the gym. I'm a big proponent of 'leave it better than you found it,'" Calhoun said. "Youngstown State really was my foundation for coaching. It really taught me so many things. Guys like Ron Strollo and Jim Tressel, I thought were just so instrumental in helping me develop as a coach and as a person. I'll always be indebted to Youngstown State."

Calhoun had received opportunities to leave YSU in the years before that, but didn't feel like it was the right time. He still felt like he had unfinished business with the Penguins.

"I just felt like I really wanted to get Youngstown State to the NCAA tournament," Calhoun said. "That was kind of my life goal when I was there. Utah State was just a basketball-crazed place, and when I went out there, I just fell in love with it."

Calhoun spoke with Strollo, YSU's athletic director, about his intentions, and Strollo indicated that he intended to hire Faulkner as his successor.

That reassured Calhoun. Knowing that there would be some stability and continuity with some familiar faces leading the program made him feel more comfortable about his decision to leave.

"I give Ron a ton of credit for keeping the hire in house. I thought it was a home-run hire," Calhoun said. "There was never a doubt in my mind that he was ready to become a head coach. What he's done there in three years -- his first year was just magnificent, one game away from going to the NCAA tournament."

Faulkner and Calhoun had often discussed trying to schedule a game during the past couple years, but they could never get it to work for logistical or financial reasons while Calhoun was at Utah State.

"The travel is so difficult, and obviously there's a huge financial piece to this game," Faulkner said. "For us, when we're trying to get these buy games, we're trying to put our team in a situation where our guys are playing in great environments where we're playing against some of the top teams in the country, because that's going to help our growth and development as a team. But when talking about the financial piece, we're always looking for these games we can bus to. That allows us to benefit as much as we can and maximize the financial piece to the equation."

But now that Calhoun is back in Ohio, it made perfect sense to both coaches to get the matchup back on the calendar for the first time since 2000.

"For in-state schools, it's really important to keep some of those connections," Calhoun said. "On our end, I think it's really beneficial for us too because I think they're a quality opponent. I think they're going to win close to 20 games, so I think it really helps us as well. ... Ultimately, you want to play good teams that are going to have good numbers to help your metrics for the NCAA tournament. So I think it makes sense for both sides."

While they may be opponents on Wednesday night, for Calhoun, YSU is still near and dear to his heart, and he says he still roots for the Penguins the other 31 games out of the year even though he's no longer in Youngstown.

"I think leading up to the game, you start to think about a lot of great memories and all your friendships that you have back in Youngstown," Calhoun said. "It was seven years of my family's life. So it's not just me, it's my children. They have so many great friends there still. It's my wife, there's just some real connections to the staff and to that community.

"We watch anytime we're not playing and Youngstown's on TV. It's been that way for two years, even when I was in Utah. ... I think it's bigger than basketball when you spend so much time with people and their families. You just develop a friendship that goes beyond sports."

Starting at /week.