Breaking News
Local Sports

Ohio can’t split private and public tourneys

By Dan Hiner 3 min read
Dan Hiner

Well, it’s time to have this debate for the third time.

Earlier in the week, the Suburban League got a petition on the Ohio High School Athletic Association’s desk that called for a referendum vote to split the public and private schools in the tournaments.

The May vote will be the third attempt to push for a split tournament, and in 1978 and 1993, both attempts obviously failed.

This time around, the principals throughout the state need to make the same decision as in years prior.

The split private and public tournaments would be a net negative for the state as a whole.

If the tournaments were to become split, eventually the question of how to distribute the teams into divisions would come up? The same issue could emerge on the public school side of things.

There are 121 private schools in the state. Take into account geography, and how would a division look and where would the cutoff be? Can Division V Cardinal Mooney compete with a Division I St. Ignatius or St. Edward if there were only two divisions? How would Warren JFK or Valley Christian contend with the Cardinals if they were in the same division?

It would also open the door for another issue that the general public rarely considers: what happens to open enrollment vs. close enrollment?

If the proposal passes, the OHSAA said it would eliminate its competitive balance procedures. The competitive balance structure moved schools up divisions based on their number of students that come from outside of their districts.

If that’s abolished, the open enrollment schools could take students from outside their district, but close enrollment districts wouldn’t be afforded that same luxury. Even if districts decided to become open enrollment, should the landscape of high school athletics determine the policies of a community?

There’s a similar number of closed enrollment districts and private schools. So the large majority of the field would be open enrollment.

Is if fair for one set of schools to take non-district students when others can’t? And then -- and this is projecting a bit -- the state would have to ask if there needs to be three tournaments for private, open enrollment and closed enrollment schools. And of course, each one of those three tournaments would need their own divisions as well.

At that point, high school athletics throughout the state would be jumping the shark.

Having a debate on whether the state should separate tournaments is one thing, but finding a way to put it into practice is another.

Dan Hiner is the sports editor for The Vindicator and Tribune Chronicle. He can be reached via email at dhiner@tribtoday.com.

Starting at /week.