Breaking News
Editorials

Despite high emotions, we must remember deer are not pets

4 min read

We have heard the skepticism raised by many who spoke out to our reporters, at meetings and in hearings about the enormous number of deer that researchers say reside in Mill Creek MetroParks.

Studies commissioned by Mill Creek MetroParks have determined there are more than 350 deer per square mile. Indeed, this number is remarkable and, yes, hard to believe.

However, most hunters and wildlife experts understand that because deer are so elusive, generally many more exist than can be seen by the naked eye.

While residents and animal lovers have pushed back strongly against the hunts, the fact is, Ohio's white-tailed deer, including those in Mill Creek MetroParks, are wild animals. They are not pets.

And the number of deer that are being targeted for removal likely will be replaced quickly in coming years.

Consider, Ohio's 2022-23 white-tailed deer hunting season closed earlier this year with 210,977 harvested deer checked, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources Division of Wildlife.

That number is up compared to the three-year average total of 193,058.

ODNR reports the number of deer taken by hunters in Mahoning County alone, during Ohio's deer hunting seasons beginning in September 2022 and lasting until February 2023, was 2,074. In Trumbull County, that number was 4,251.

Now, deer hunts in Mill Creek MetroParks are estimated to harvest between 66 and 133 deer. Separate from the hunts are an additional estimated 30 deer that will be harvested through a deer reduction phase called "targeted removal" that involves U.S. Department of Agriculture-paid sharpshooters. That means a combined maximum expected removal of about 90 to 160 deer this year.

If those numbers are achieved, they would equal only 4% to 8% of the total deer harvested in all of Mahoning County this year.

The fact is, hunting deer and culling herds has become a necessary part of managing deer herds across Ohio and other parts of the country.

Now, the culling process has begun.

So far this month, 38 deer have been harvested from Mill Creek MetroParks by licensed bow hunters. The deer management plan will include hunts at nine park locations covering 1,942 acres. The largest of those parks is Hitchcock Woods, which has 489 acres. It is estimated that 16 to 32 deer will be harvested this year in Hitchcock Woods.

While few wildlife experts would predict any deer herd would grow indefinitely, most still support hunting or culling herds because without doing so, the deer population ultimately negatively affects the health of the herd and impacts humans, said Steve Merchant, who manages the deer population program at the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, according to a 2017 story by the Center of the American Experiment, a Minnesota think tank that focuses on that state's economy, education, health care, family and more.

"It's a biological system. It would take care of itself," said Merchant, but "you'd have lots of deer that would die of starvation and disease."

Without herd management, damage from deer also can go well beyond just suburban backyards. Deer damage also can impact agricultural crops, deer / car collisions, transmission of Lyme disease and the over browsing of habitat needed by deer and other wildlife. Another potential problem involves overgrazing. As more deer compete for the same food, farmland, gardens and forests begin to experience serious damage.

In Ohio, the statewide deer population hovers around 680,000. That number is controlled through regulated harvests managed each year by the Ohio Division of Wildlife.

Indeed, we understand that many Ohioans and Valley residents enjoy the sight of wildlife, and we understand the strong emotions that come with this love of wildlife. However, the harsh reality is sometimes it just becomes necessary to cull wild herds.

The public has had its opportunity to be heard. The courts have considered the cases. And now the hunts have begun.

We urge neighbors of Mill Creek MetroParks to realize these animals are not pets, and for the sake of the deer and the park, thinning the herd is not inhumane. It is a necessity.

Starting at /week.