Trending
We are extremely disappointed at Youngstown Board of Education's abrupt decision to replace Superintendent Justin Jennings after his equally abrupt exodus earlier this month.
The board's unnecessarily quick action in replacing Jennings with his former deputy superintendent of teaching, learning and leadership, Jeremy Batchelor, came last week without so much as an employment ad or any consideration for a broader search. From our vantage point, the decision was a great disservice to this community.
In the days after Jennings announced his resignation, about a year into his three-year contract, board President Tiffany Patterson told our reporter that the board would consider exploring help from the Ohio School Boards Association or other possible internal options. At the time, we admit we were baffled when Patterson added that she hoped to wait to explore permanent options until after the November election for board of education members.
That surprise did not stem from the plan to search far and wide, but rather from Patterson's proposed delay, which we believed was unwarranted and unfair to students, parents, employees and the community as a whole. Indeed, the type of broad search that this appointment warranted would take a significant amount of time. So why wait?
Imagine our subsequent surprise -- and probably that of the community, too -- when the board did an unexpected about face and moved unanimously to instead permanently fill the post just a few weeks later without any search at all!
The board announced July 3, three days after Jennings officially departed, that they decided instead to hire Batchelor as the permanent superintendent at Youngstown City Schools. Batchelor's new salary has not yet been announced. As deputy superintendent, he earned $139,000 per year. His predecessor earned $190,000 as superintendent.
Certainly, this type of taxpayer-funded salary demands review of all options for the most qualified leader!
Now, let us be clear. Our problem is not necessarily with the selection of Batchelor. Rather, it is with the board's decision to do so without the scrutiny that it warranted.
Additionally, the board's inexplicably quick action effectively eliminates any public discussion or input from the residents.
Certainly, it behooves every board of education in the market for a new superintendent to search broadly, examining the many qualified candidates who are sure to apply.
For many years, the Youngstown City School District has faced great challenges, including struggles with the academic success of its students. Even under state academic control triggered by House Bill 70, that problem has not diminished. After working so hard to shed state control and return to local governance, we had hoped our duly elected board of education members would raise the bar and strive for the excellence they insisted they could achieve under local control.
That's why we are so baffled by the latest decision to accept status quo without an attempt to look any further.
Frankly, the board made the same mistake when they moved Jennings from the role as district CEO under state control to superintendent under local control. In fact, we used this very space last year to urge the local board to avoid hiring Jennings without looking any further. The board ignored our urging and moved forward with the decision.
Now history is repeating itself.
Just as we said of Jennings, we say again about Batchelor. If he truly is the best person for this position, then he would have shined when stacked up against other superintendent candidates who might have emerged in a much wider search.
Unfortunately, the residents of Youngstown never will see that comparison.
Now, we only hope -- but, sadly, have little reason to expect -- that this board of education will maintain an extremely high bar with expectations of the administrator for greatly improved measurable results in student performance.