Trending
Girard's Democrat voters have a heavy weight on their shoulders in selecting a nominee for mayor.
Both candidates, incumbent James Melfi and challenger Mark Zuppo, offer both assets and liabilities.
Melfi, who has led the city of 9,500 since 2000, certainly has experience in his corner. During that tenure, he helped remove the city from fiscal emergency, helped ensure giant pipe maker Vallourec's growth into Girard and spearheaded the project to obtain federal funds to clear the former Leatherworks factory site for commercial and recreational development.
Yet, on other critical fronts, Melfi has fallen short.
One of our biggest tiffs with the mayor has come with his commitment to speed cameras, which in one form or another, have been a city fixture for many years. Melfi argues the cameras promote not just revenue, but safety.
"If you're trying to improve the community, getting speeders under control is essential," he told this newspaper's editorial board.
We have no qualms with controlling speeding motorists to promote public safety. We do, however, have serious reservations about how Girard has chosen to crack down on speeders -- via cameras held by police officers often hidden from passing motorists' views.
Those motorists lose some level of due process rights without fair warning of flashing lights behind them and at least an opportunity to defend themselves to the police officer making a traffic stop.
The cameras' impact on affecting drivers' behavior is highly questionable as well. Police officers hiding on bridge overpasses, out of view, provide no incentive for average drivers to slow down and drive responsibly.
What's more, the money the city rakes in from speeding fines is treated as a capital improvement tax and targeted toward things like new police cars, street improvements and recreation. Policing for profit falls under the rubric of taxation without representation.
And not all that revenue goes to Girard coffers. Hundreds of thousands of dollars collected annually goes to a Tennessee company with which Girard contracts.
But Melfi's passionate embrace of speed cameras is not the only reason we cannot endorse the incumbent for a seventh term. The mayor has failed to ensure that vacant positions up for hire in the city are properly posted and advertised in an effort to attract the best candidates from the largest pool possible. Failure to do so leaves the door open to charges of cronyism in municipal hiring.
Melfi told our editorial board the lack of postings had not been brought to his attention but that, moving forward, he now plans to do so. We'll hold him to that vow.
Like Melfi, challenger Zuppo has no shortage of public service to the city and its school district. He has been city treasurer for 10 years and served on the Girard Board of Education for seven years. He, too, has his share of accomplishments. Among them is his institution of new initiatives targeting delinquent taxpayers that have increased income tax collections and kept the city in the black. He's also been actively involved for decades in the city's and school district's recreation programs.
We are pleased to hear Zuppo say he personally opposes the use of speed cameras and, if elected, he would work to phase out their usage.
Still, Zuppo has liabilities.
First, there is his poor attendance at city council meetings. As city treasurer, Zuppo has missed 40 of 57 public meetings over the past three years. Zuppo attempted to ease our minds on this weakness by pointing out he rarely misses board of education meetings and, he pledges, if elected mayor, he will attend all council meetings.
While we could overlook some of those absences, Zuppo's hard stance in support of developing the Girard Lakes property makes us seriously question his ability to oversee the city with sound fiscal responsibility.
Many in Girard, including the mayor, recognize the 1995 purchase of the lakes for millions of dollars as a water source as a boondoggle. Melfi rightly calls the property a white elephant. He said the city has since learned no grants are available to extend waterlines because no one lives there. Melfi also said it would cost $8 million to $10 million to extend water and sewer to the property -- money the city clearly does not have. And lest city taxpayers forget, the ill-advised purchase was the prime reason the city entered fiscal emergency in the first place.
Beyond that troubling issue, however, is another that Melfi raised during his interview. He contends that Zuppo urged a city official to consider contracting with his former private business associate to disinfect offices during the COVID-19 pandemic. Zuppo acknowledges that he introduced a friend to the police chief about a potential contract, but maintains he was not involved directly with the company nor stood to profit from any resulting contract. With no proof to the contrary, we must accept Zuppo's explanation, but we still question the intent.
So, the decision on whom to select must rest on each voter. Given our consistent objections to speed camera use, we simply cannot support Melfi. Beyond that, we believe voters must consider their personal beliefs on this issue and the others we've outlined herein.
editorial@vindy.com