Breaking News
Latest News

Youngstown police praise Flock cameras

City seeks to renew contract for 56 devices

By DAVID SKOLNICK 5 min read

YOUNGSTOWN - Youngstown police said Flock Safety cameras are a valuable tool though the response at a public forum to the use of the automatic license plate readers was mixed.

During a Tuesday presentation at the Eugenia Atkinson Recreational Center, police Lt. Mohammad Awad pointed to statistics that showed violent crimes — homicides, rapes, burglaries, larcenies, motor vehicle thefts and arsons — declined by 12.4% during the first 24 months of the city having Flock cameras, September 2024 to this past August, compared with the previous two years without the license plate readers.

When challenged by Flock opponents at the event, Awad, the chief of detectives, acknowledged that the cameras were helpful and could be attributed to some of the decrease, but couldn't say what percentage of the decrease in crime is the result of the license plate readers.

Awad said: "The numbers are the numbers. You interpret the numbers."

He added: "From my experience, I attribute a lot of that to Flock. But not just Flock."

Mayor Derrick McDowell said Flock helped with about 100 cases.

Awad pointed to several examples in which Flock was able to find violent criminals in a shorter time than it would have taken officers without them.

Awad said: "The case for retention rests on documented results."

The city signed a two-year contract with Flock that took effect Sept. 1, 2024, for 56 cameras. The first year cost $188,900, which included installation, with the second year costing $168,000. There is a recurring annual cost of $168,000 with the latest year starting Sept. 1 and running through Aug. 31, 2027.

McDowell and Awad said city council would soon vote on the program's future.

McDowell said no one is asking for an increase in the Flock contract or more cameras.

"We want to renew the contract," he said.

Police Chief Sharon Cole said: "One of my biggest responsibilities is keeping our community safe while making sure we maintain your trust. Flock cameras are just another tool that we use to fight crime, identify suspects, solve cases and continue to work to reduce crimes in our neighborhoods. But we also understand that when we bring technology like this, people have questions and concerns on how it's being used."

Awad said a case number is required before any Flock search is completed, the information obtained by the cameras are shared with other law enforcement for only legitimate police purposes and the city doesn't use it for immigration reasons.

"We want to reduce crime," Awad said.

But a number of people at the meeting said the technology is flawed, makes mistakes and can be abused. Also, they said Flock could sell the information collected in Youngstown for improper reasons.

Awad said technology can make mistakes, which is why the city police has officers verify license plates before making a stop when they are picked up by Flock cameras for possible criminal activity.

"Nothing's perfect," Awad said. "It's up to us to verify the information. If Flock makes a mistake, we put the onus on us to make sure it's the correct information."

One resident said that an older woman she knows in the city got confused and ended up in Pennsylvania, and through the use of Flock cameras she was found and safely brought home.

Flock cameras have come under considerable national scrutiny with reports about police officers, including in Ohio, improperly using the data for personal reasons or sharing with federal agencies for immigration enforcement.

Critics point to privacy issues, mass tracking of citizens, and the lack of transparency and public accountability.

Nationally, more than 120,000 Flock cameras are installed in about 7,000 communities and take photos of about 20 billion vehicles each month.

About 400 entities in Ohio use the cameras, including several in the Mahoning Valley.

Flock doesn't just sell the cameras to law enforcement. It also sells them to school districts, universities, homeowner associations, parking lot/deck operators, apartment complexes, companies and stores.

State Sen. Al Cutrona, R-Canfield, introduced legislation on Sept. 14 to ensure information collected by Flock cameras is used appropriately.

The bill would prohibit any government entity collecting Flock camera data from sharing it with a third party or for personal use.

The bill wouldn't permit any government agency in the state that uses Flock cameras to share data with an outside party or for such an entity to solicit the data. Also, the data could only be saved in the system for up to 10 days before being automatically deleted.

Under Cutrona's bill, anyone caught using Flock cameras or its collected data for personal use - rather than as part of an active law enforcement case - could be charged with a fourth-degree felony, which is punishable by up to 18 months in prison and a $5,000 fine.

The bill was referred Sept. 30 to the Senate Armed Services, Veterans Affairs and Public Safety Committee. It is set to have its first committee hearing today.

McDowell withdrew legislation that was to be in front of city council at its Oct. 21 meeting that sought to allow revenue collected from those caught by unstaffed cameras speeding in school zones to pay for half of the Flock's annual bill. At the time, McDowell said he pulled the proposal to give citizens an opportunity to discuss the Flock cameras.

The city's entire $168,000 bill to Flock Safety is paid out of the police budget. The proposal would have had $84,000, half of it, come from speed camera revenue because city officials say about half of the Flock cameras in the city are in school zones.

Starting at /week.