Trending
YOUNGSTOWN - Nearly two and a half years since downtown on-street parking enforcement essentially stopped, the city's board of control today will approve a $30,000 contract for a company to perform an "initial analysis" to revive it starting in spring 2027.
The board will vote to hire LAZ Parking LLC for the work that includes "parking analysis, development of enforcement strategy, fee analysis, public outreach and business relations," according to the proposal. Based in Hartford, Connecticut, with a regional office in Columbus, LAZ is one of the largest privately held parking management companies in the country.
LAZ was selected to do the study from three companies that sought the work with the other two being Premium Parking and ABM Parking Services, said Charles Shasho, the city's deputy director of public works.
Shasho said: "Parking enforcement is important for downtown. It's necessary. People are occupying spaces for extended periods of time. It's a free for all. It needs to be reined in. There will be parking zones. We need to get rid of all of the existing ordinances as none of them are any good because of construction" work done in the past few years to downtown streets.
LAZ's initial analysis will take two or three months with plans for enforcement to start in the spring after a public outreach effort, Shasho said.
The city discontinued its downtown enforcement contract with ABM after removing all of its meters in June 2024. There is no enforcement of hourly on-street parking in the downtown area except in some extreme circumstances.
When ABM was used, the city was paying about $10,000 a month for enforcement and only $2,000 in tickets were issued per month.
The LAZ proposal calls for those parking downtown at on-street spots to either scan a QR code or use a parking app to pay, Shasho said. There might be kiosks where people can pay, Shasho said.
A number of the paid downtown parking lots use a similar QR code or parking app method with some having kiosks.
The city still has to decide what the price for parking would be and if parking would be for limited hours, if additional hours could be added or if there would be a price for people to park for several hours, Shasho said.
"It's a lot to go through," Shasho said. "We want to run it in the black. It was costing money for the old system."
The plan is to hire LAZ for enforcement, Shasho said.
Shasho said: "They won't get a share of the tickets because that encourages predatory practices. They'll get a flat rate to do enforcement. We'll negotiate a contract. We'll start with very soft enforcement throughout the winter."
The enforcement would be in the downtown area as well as on Lincoln Avenue and Phelps Street by Youngstown State University, Shasho said.
On-street parking in downtown has been a long-stalled issue.
City council on Sept. 17, 2025, permitted the board of control to spend up to $100,000 to advertise for proposals for parking enforcement services. More than a year later, the board of control will finally act.
The issue was first discussed Jan. 29, 2025, by council's parking committee - and didn't get too far. It was the first time that council committee had met since 2019. At that 2019 meeting, the discussion was to take legislative action to put tire boots and/or windshield barnacles on vehicles of the worst repeat parking ticket offenders. That proposal went nowhere.
The city eliminated on-street meters and ended the ABM contract in June 2024 to encourage people to come downtown. But many of those who work downtown ended up parking in the spots while at their jobs making it more challenging for others to find parking.
Also, with no enforcement, plenty of cars park in spaces that have "no parking" signs without getting tickets.
The city in July 2024 eliminated fees at a 114-space parking lot it owns on Commerce and Phelps streets, behind the dormant 20 Federal Place building. That was initially supposed to last for six months, but it continues.