Breaking News
Local News

SOBE failed to pay $37K in property taxes

By DAVID SKOLNICK 5 min read

YOUNGSTOWN - SOBE Thermal Energy Systems LLC, the financially plagued downtown Youngstown steam heat utility, owes $37,404.94 in delinquent property taxes and is unable to pay them.

SOBE owes the money on four parcels, totaling 2.528 acres, at its 205 North Ave. location that was due this year for 2025.

John Collins, SOBE's receiver since Feb. 17, said Wednesday: "We're delinquent and it's a significant amount of money. We can't pay it at this point in time. The county can file a tax foreclosure, but that will take a while. As sad as this is, it's not the most pressing issue in front of us."

SOBE is hemorrhaging money as its expenses far exceed its revenues.

The company, which provides steam heat to a majority of downtown, will be out of money by late January or early February, at the latest, unless the state and/or federal government intervenes and bails it out, Collins said.

Collins said of the delinquent tax bills: "We're unable to pay. We have other bills that are far more pressing - boiler, Enbridge and salary. I can't pay the former receiver. I can't pay myself or (Michael Moran, SOBE's legal counsel). This is a crisis and the crisis is getting worse every day. We're hopeful (about a bailout), but nothing concrete seems to pass. We can only hope we receive money from the state of Ohio to operate for a year so the powers that be can find a permanent solution."

The tax bills were initially sent to the company's Dublin, Ohio, office as that is listed as the taxpayer's address for each parcel. SOBE, under CEO David Ferro, abandoned the Youngstown plant when a boiler it was renting to provide heat for most of downtown was repossessed and the company owed millions of dollars in unpaid expenses. A Mahoning County Common Pleas Court judge agreed with a request from the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio on Sept. 26, 2025, to put the company in receivership under Reg Martin.

The delinquent tax bills made their way to the Youngstown location. Collins said future property tax bills will now be sent there, but there's still no money to pay them.

The four parcels have a total appraised value of $1,304,990, according to the county auditor's website.

Collins said: "I don't know if it's worth anything. We can file a complaint with the board of revisions to reduce the value. That would significantly help with (future) taxes, but not with the delinquent taxes."

After numerous problems with keeping boilers Martin rented for SOBE operating and complaints from customers, the PUCO moved to have Martin removed and Collins replaced him Feb. 17.

Martin and Kenneth R. Goldberg, SOBE's former legal counsel, are owed $55,570 in back payments that the utility company cannot pay.

SOBE negotiated a $724,324.82 settlement in July with the Enbridge Gas Co. for past due bills of $2,226,662.62. The agreement called for SOBE to pay $40,240.25 a month, that was to start in August, for 18 months on top of its regular gas bill. To date, SOBE hasn't made a single payment to Enbridge for the settlement amount.

Collins said: "They have not said anything, but they could say they want it all and we'd have to go to PUCO to change the payment schedule."

SOBE is current on its regular Enbridge gas bill, which was about $64,000 last month, Collins said.

"It will increase for every month between now and February," Collins said. "Enbridge's bill will be $80,000 to $90,000 for next month. We'll be able to pay that too, but it gets difficult after that."

In order to save money, SOBE returned two rented boilers, one was 650-horsepower and the other was 250-horsepower, in late July-early August to Power Mechanical Inc., the Newport News, Virginia, company that leases the boilers.

By keeping an 800-horsepower boiler, it reduced its monthly payments for the equipment from $58,000 to $28,400.

But SOBE needs a second 800-horsepower boiler as a backup in case the other one goes down, and one was delivered Nov. 4 by Power Mechanical.

The backup boiler doubles the rental cost for SOBE to $56,800.

SOBE has about $120,000 left from a $750,000 payment given to it by Enbridge as part of the company's $1 million settlement with the PUCO over the Realty Tower explosion investigation. SOBE uses that money to lease the boilers.

Collins said that money will be depleted no later than late January or early February - leaving its customers without heat during what is typically the coldest time of the year.

Collins said he hasn't told Power Mechanical that it only has enough money to pay for a few more months for the boilers.

Collins said: "They're getting paid. There's a payment due next week. I just hope someone comes through. It's coming close to running out of money."

Emergency rate increases approved June 24 by the PUCO, which took effect six days later, were supposed to help generate money for the struggling company. But with several customers not paying or getting off the system, those rate hikes have failed to generate revenue.

The PUCO emergency rate hikes called for 13 of the SOBE's then 23 customers, to pay 93% increases for the non-heating season between May and October. Two others were to pay 92% more with one at 91% and two at 36%. The five other customers are paying between 64% and 80% more.

With only 19 customers currently on the system, those increases likely increased to existing users.

That same PUCO decision called for the rate to increase by another 162% for 14 of SOBE's customers with one charged 163% more between November and April and two billed 85% more. The six others were to be charged increases between 123% and 159%.

But Moran and Collins said that additional rate increase, peaking at 163%, is not necessarily correct and is too high.

SOBE lost three customers last month and had to disconnect another - 22 Market Street Ohio LLC, which is developing the former Mahoning National Bank building - for being delinquent with payments.

Starting at /week.