Breaking News
Local News

Contract for wastewater project on hold

By DAVID SKOLNICK 4 min read
Shasho

YOUNGSTOWN - The awarding of a contract for the first phase of a significant wastewater improvement project was postponed because of city council's refusal to approve 14% annual sewer rate increases for the next five years.

Charles Shasho, deputy director of public works, said he chose not to submit the proposal for consideration Thursday by the board of control until "We get the rates squared away. We can't start the work until January. I didn't want to rush it. It's still going to be awarded. The bid is fine. Hopefully, we'll have it on the next" board agenda.

The board of control next meets Dec. 3, the day after council's Dec. 2 meeting.

The city opened bids on Nov. 6 for the project with the lowest of four proposals of $2,187,690 submitted by Marucci & Gaffney Excavating Co. of Youngstown.

Right after the bids were opened, Shasho said the contract would be in front of the board of control at its next meeting, which was Thursday.

The engineer's estimate for this first phase of a wet weather facility project was $4,323,825. When city council voted Aug. 17 to permit the board of control to seek bids and enter into contracts for the first phase, the estimate was $3,779,391.

The estimate was increased after discussions with potential bidders about what would be needed for the work, Shasho said.

The first phase is initial site improvements for the wet weather facility, a project estimated to cost $228 million and required by a federal consent decree.

The work includes demolition, mass grading, stormwater work, installing a waterline, site security, electrical duct banks and rebuilding a portion of Williamson Avenue extension that goes through the city's wastewater treatment plant property.

The work is scheduled to start in January and be done by June.

The wet weather facility is the third part of more than $400 million in projects by the city to improve its wastewater system as mandated by the federal government.

The 80-million-gallon-per-day wet weather facility will have a number of structures and a tunnel to treat excess combined sewage during heavy rainstorms and then release the water.

Overall, there will be seven projects requiring bids for the wet weather facility with the first one being, by far, the least expensive. The city will pay for the first phase, as well as about $3.5 million for the utility relocations, out of the wastewater fund with the rest borrowed from the state, Shasho said.

At a Tuesday meeting, council refused to approve 14% sewer rate increases for the next five years to pay for the federally mandated work with members saying the administration needs to do more to cut costs to reduce the proposed hikes. Council chose to keep the rate increases as well as requests to move forward with two wet weather facility projects, at a total estimated cost of $100 million, in its finance committee for further discussion.

Mayor Derrick McDowell said the city is talking with officials from Mahoning and Trumbull counties to change contracts Youngstown has with them to take their sewage to pay more, which would eventually reduce the cost to Youngstown residents, but it's going to take time.

Without the rate increase - and a study states 14% is the least amount the city can charge - Youngstown won't be able to pay its debt service on the projects, get state funding to do the required work, and it could result in delays to the work.

At Thursday's meeting, the board of control agreed to pay $53,090 to Genesis, The New Beginning Ministries for nine parcels on Franklin Avenue and Gibson Street needed for the wet weather facility.

The board also voted to reduce a contract by $100,338.88 with Lindy Paving, a Pennsylvania company with an office in Struthers, for a resurfacing job.

Less pavement repairs and asphalt quantities were needed for the work, resulting in the deduction, Shasho said.

The project was to Gibson Street from Poland to Indianola avenues, Liberty Road from Atkinson to Bott avenues, and Shehy Street from Lincoln Park Drive to Loveless Avenue.

With the deduction, the project's costs went from $766,977.26 to $666,638.38. The city's original estimate for the work was $1.13 million.

Also Thursday, the board hired LA Parking LLC for $30,000 to perform an "initial analysis" on downtown on-street parking to revive it starting in spring 2027.

LAZ's contract calls for it to do parking analysis, develop enforcement strategy, determine fees for parking and handle public outreach.

The city discontinued its downtown enforcement contract with ABM Parking Services after removing all of its meters in June 2024. There is no enforcement of hourly on-street parking in the downtown area except in some extreme circumstances.

Starting at /week.