Trending
YOUNGSTOWN -- The state of Ohio responded on Tuesday to Austintown Trustee Steve Kent's request for a change of venue in his upcoming criminal trial.
In a motion signed by Attorney General Dave Yost, the state refutes assertions made in a Friday motion by defense attorney John Juhasz that media coverage of Kent's case has tainted the jury pool, and takes Kent to task for the request.
"It is a shame that Kent, who has asked for a jury trial, has so little faith or confidence in the citizens from Mahoning County that he finds it necessary to attack and disparage them in advance of a jury summons even being issued, and ask the court to presume that all potential jurors are a biased and unfair group of citizens who will exhibit a disdain for both their oath and the jury selection process," it states.
Kent is due in Mahoning County Common Pleas Judge John Durkin's courtroom on Monday on charges of sexual battery. Prosecutors allege Kent had an inappropriate relationship with a student while he was the resource officer for Poland Seminary High School and that he later attempted to destroy evidence.
Juhasz had filed a motion requesting a change of venue, on the basis that media coverage of Kent has been excessive and therefore the court cannot empanel an impartial jury in Mahoning County.
Juhasz compared the case to that of Cleveland doctor Sam Sheppard, who was convicted of murdering his wife in 1954 and exonerated 12 years later when the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that media coverage had tainted the case and violated Sheppard's right to due process under the 14th Amendment.
The state, however, cites multiple cases that seek to invalidate that comparison.
Yost's motion asserts that the defendant cannot rely solely on allegations of unfair or excessive media coverage "to claim that the court cannot accept the jurors' promises for fairness without a showing of more factors indicating bias."
Citing Nebraska Press Association v. Stuart, the motion states that "massive pretrial publicity does not inevitably lead to jurors who cannot sit fairly on the case and base their decision solely on the evidence and testimony heard from the witness stand inside the court room."
The motion points to jury questionnaires and direct questions asked of jurors as "a sturdy foundation to assess fitness for jury service."
The state's motion says changes of venue should be considered only after honest attempts to empanel an impartial local jury have been unsuccessful. Venue changes are uncommon in Mahoning County and in Ohio for this reason, the motion states. "When such jury selection process has been conducted in this county and across the State of Ohio in highly publicized cases, there has been no need to grant a change of venue."
The motion cites the case of Anthony Sowell, who was convicted in 2011 of murdering 11 women in Cleveland. Despite large-scale media coverage, a local jury was selected, and the case proceeded to a conviction and imposition of a death sentence, a decision later upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court. The state also cites other cases with similar outcomes.