Trending
Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost filed a seven-count civil lawsuit against what he called a "phony charity that falsely claimed" it was collecting donations on behalf of the Second Harvest Food Bank of the Mahoning Valley to help East Palestine residents impacted by the Feb. 3 train derailment .
Yost filed the lawsuit Tuesday in Columbiana County Common Pleas Court against Ohio Clean Water Fund and Michael E. Peppel Jr. of Leetonia, its founder and principal, seeking a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction.
Shortly after the derailment of the Norfolk Southern train in East Palestine, Ohio Clean Water started soliciting charitable donations for the village even before the entity was incorporated, according to the AG's office. It incorporated March 3, according to a filing with the Ohio secretary of state.
Peppel claimed a partnership with the food bank, when there wasn't one, and as of March 20 received $141,183 from 3,269 donors and has given only $10,000 to the food bank.
In text messages, Peppel's company said it was raising money for bottled water and food for those impacted by the East Palestine train derailment and falsely claimed he was working with the food bank, according to the lawsuit.
The organization operates out of Peppel's Leetonia home on Butcher Road.
Ohio Clean Water Fund didn't stop accepting money until Monday so it isn't known how much more it was given.
The lawsuit seeks "to halt Peppel's illegal activity, prohibit him from engaging in additional charitable solicitations and preserve existing charitable assets."
Yost said: "The idea that somebody would so brazenly exploit a disaster situation and the good hearts of people who want to help is unconscionable. I'm mad as hell about this, and we're going to make sure this sham charity gets shut down."
Attempts on Tuesday to contact Peppel were unsuccessful.
The fund's website has been shut down. A screenshot of a page on the former website has a photo of an East Palestine mural on its municipal court building with the Ohio Clean Water Fund logo and "thanks for your support" written below it.
Peppel also incorporated Ohio Valley Strategies LLC on Feb. 16, according to a filing with the Ohio secretary of state. It isn't known what that company does.
Michael Iberis, executive director of the food bank, said of Peppel: "He was lying. He was untruthful. He used our name without our knowledge. We only found out when people throughout the country contacted us and said they were being solicited by him and did we know about it. We said, 'No.'"
After receiving the calls and text messages, Iberis said the food bank -- which serves Mahoning, Trumbull and Columbiana counties -- posted on its website that it had nothing to do with the Ohio Clean Water Fund.
"It's nothing but a scam," Iberis said.
After that web posting, Peppel gave $10,000 to the food bank on March 17, Iberis said.
"Kudos go out to Attorney General Dave Yost for acting so quickly," Iberis said. "People are waiting to see how swiftly and severely (Peppel) will be punished."
The AG's lawsuit says of the $141,183 raised as of March 20 by Peppel's company, at least $91,769 purportedly went to "data fees" and $14,118 purportedly went to "agency fees."
The lawsuit seeks restitution, compensatory and punitive damages as well as civil penalties against Peppel and his organization.
The lawsuit wants to require Peppel and his company to provide an accounting of all money collected and spent, dissolve Ohio Clean Water Fund and give the assets to the attorney general's office to distribute for charitable purposes, appoint a receiver to take possession of all assets, stop Peppel from soliciting in Ohio for charitable purposes and prohibit him from creating any nonprofit organizations in the state.
The lawsuit accuses Peppel and his organization of violating seven state laws: committing deceptive acts or practices, misrepresenting contributions as for a charitable organization without written authorization, misleading persons as to material facts concerning solicitation, failure to register as a charitable organization, unlawful professional solicitation, breach of common law fiduciary duties and breach of statutory fiduciary duties.
dskolnick@vindy.com
dskolnick@tribtoday.com