Breaking News
Local News

Rape trial touches on 9-year gap to prosecute

By Ed Runyan 5 min read

YOUNGSTOWN -- Presumably, the 9-year gap between Sept. 5, 2013, when Franklin Herns is accused of raping an 18-year-old ex-girlfriend, and summer 2022, when Herns was indicted, will be part of defense arguments at the end of his trial.

Mahoning County Assistant Prosecutor Caitlyn Andrews touched on the matter during opening statements. Defense attorneys asked a question about it when the alleged rape victim was testifying.

Also presumably central to the trial is the demeanor of the woman, who was the first witness Tuesday when testimony began in Herns' rape trial in Mahoning County Common Pleas Court.

The woman, 28, told jurors in the courtroom of Judge Anthony Donofrio that she is a stay-at-home mother of four who dated Herns when she was 16 or 17 and living with her mom on West Boston Avenue at the time of the alleged rape.

She and Herns had broken up between three and seven days before the incident, she said.

She was at home alone waiting for a carpet cleaner and had left the door unlocked when Herns "walked in," she said. She was "initially surprised" to see him, then they "argued for a while, then he took my phone," took it to the side door of the house and "proceeded to go through it," she testified.

At that point, "things got rather heated, things got physical," then got "more physical," she said.

In response to questioning by Andrews, the woman said "absolutely not" when asked whether she had any intention of having sex with him that day.

THE ALLEGATION

When asked to explain the "physical" part, she said: "First he grabbed my arm, then he grabbed my neck, he choked me and slapped me a couple of times, he punched me in my ribs, my face, and then he grabbed me by my neck and pushed me against the wall."

She said Herns then pushed her onto a sofa and raped her. She tried to fight him off, but she weighed less than 100 pounds, and he weighed about 200. He raped her for about 15 minutes, she said, and he held one hand on her neck during the entire rape. She said she "kicked and screamed the whole time."

He demanded that she take a shower, which she did, and then he left with her phone, she said.

The carpet cleaners arrived, and "they really didn't want anything to do with the situation," as far as helping her call 911, so she went to a neighbor's house and called 911 from there.

She said he bit her on her inner thigh, and it "left a mark."

She said the thoughts that went through her head when she was being raped were: "My value is being taken. I am no longer valuable because every move he makes, he is decreasing my worth."

She said that "for a long time I struggled with that, but therapy, meditation and support helped."

She spoke to a police officer before going to the hospital, where a rape kit was performed. She told a nurse the details of her previous relationship with Herns, and the nurse took photos of the bruising on the woman's neck and ribs.

Later, she went to the Youngstown Police Department, where she talked to two male detectives and a female social worker. The police officers handed her a form to sign, and she signed it.

PROSECUTION

She said the officers did not thoroughly explain the form to her but she learned later it was a form saying she did not want to go forward with prosecution. If she had known, she would not have signed it, she said.

In July 2022, Detective Jessica Shields, head of the Special Victims Unit at Youngstown Police Department, interviewed the woman again about her rape allegations, the woman testified. Things were different this time, the woman said.

"I felt like she actually cared about what was going on with me," the woman said. She decided to go forward with the prosecution at that point, she agreed.

Defense attorney Nick Cerni asked the woman if she reached out to anyone to ask about "following up on this case" during the nine years between the Sept. 5, 2013, allegation and when Shields reached out to her in 2022.

"Why would I?" she said.

"Is that a no?" Cerni asked.

"No one cared to do anything with the report, so no is the answer," she said.

Police detective Chad Zubal, who also testified Tuesday, was a patrol officer in 2013. He was the officer who responded to her home the day of the incident.

Zubal said he noticed that she had injuries to the right side of her face, and her face and jaw were swollen, causing her trouble speaking. Zubal requested an ambulance and convinced the woman to go to the hospital.

Zubal said the woman told him Herns came into the house uninvited and "immediately punched her in the face, immediately choking her, pushed her down on a couch" and raped her.

Defense attorney Tom Zena asked Zubal if the woman told him the punch in the face took place before any talking, and Zubal agreed she did. "That's how she explained it, yes," Zubal said.

erunyan@vindy.com

Starting at /week.