Breaking News
Local News

Warren nursing home confirms 22 COVID-19 deaths in December

By Ed Runyan 6 min read

By ED RUNYAN

Staff writer

WARREN -- Todd Stein, a co-owner of Gillette Nursing Home on Elm Road, says his facility had 22 COVID-19 deaths in December, but the facility did everything it could to keep the virus out and to handle the outbreak that occurred.

"This is my family-owned business. We've been doing this since 1936. We have a great reputation in the community," Stein said on Friday.

"This has been tragic. You do not understand; we lost (an employee). I was standing in the Trumbull Memorial Hospital parking lot when they took her off of the ventilator," he said of a worker who died from COVID-19.

The facility had two more COVID-19 deaths in January but has not had any new infections since Jan. 1, he said.

Because of the number of staff members who contracted the virus in December, staffing fell to low levels, so he and his brother, fellow owner Doug Stein, worked in the COVID-19 unit themselves. Doug later tested positive, Todd said.

"How many owners do you know who were in a positive COVID-19 unit taking care of patients? How many CEOs? My brother and I were there every day trying to take care of the patients that were positive," he said.

"All I can tell you is … the Ohio Department of Health came in and said there's nothing more you guys could have done. You guys are doing more than any facility we've been into," Todd said.

John May, deputy director of the Warren Board of Health, told the newspaper earlier this week that one Warren long-term care facility had 23 COVID-19 deaths in December, and it was a big reason why the county's nursing-home death count was high in December. May later revised that number to 22.

The ODH reports the number of COVID-19 deaths at long-term care facilities such as nursing homes in each county each week on its website. It does not identify the nursing homes that have had deaths, it only gives the total of COVID-19 deaths in each county.

May did not identify Gillette as the nursing home with the 22 deaths last week but did so Friday after the newspaper made a public records request to him and the Ohio Department of Health. Late Thursday, an ODH spokesperson said the agency was still working on the request.

May said earlier this week the facility with the 22 deaths (Gillette) also had not followed certain CDC guidelines regarding COVID-19 employees coming to work after testing positive for the virus and showing symptoms. And, the facility also had not reported its deaths to the Warren Board of Health, May said.

The Ohio Department of Health investigated the issue of employees reporting for work with symptoms in mid-December and found that six staff members were working with patients despite having symptoms.

Two of the COVID-19 positive workers had "slight (nasal) stuffiness," two had "no taste and smell," one had a mild cough she had all winter and lost her sense of taste. One had no sense of smell, according to an Ohio Department of Health investigative report obtained by the newspaper.

Todd Stein said Gillette is appealing the ODH findings on the grounds that the facility was in a "crisis situation" that allows the use of symptomatic COVID-19 employees.

Paula Zigmont, Gillette's director of nursing, said CDC guidelines state a facility should not use COVID-19 employees who are mildly symptomatic, "but at the time we were using them, we were in a crisis situation."

The ODH said Gillette needed to get approval to use those employees, "but we had already talked to (Warren) Health Department" epidemiologist Jacob Marvin, and "he didn't know if he had the authorization to give us that approval," Zigmont said.

In an ODH investigative report, Marvin is quoted as telling an ODH investigator he spoke with the facility's director of nursing, who notified him the facility was having staffing issues. She told him Gillette would no longer use COVID-19 staff with mild symptoms if the Warren Board of Health helped the facility get more staffing, the report stated.

Marvin stated he didn't know whether Gillette got more staffing, but he never gave permission for Gillette to use COVID-19-positive staff.

"Our local health department said he felt he was not qualified to make that decision," Todd Stein said. "We (felt) the best decision was to move forward."

He added, "My employees were given the option if they wanted to work, you were paid almost double your wages. If you were unable to work, you were able to go home, and I was paying you for 14 days to be off work."

With regard to reporting COVID-19 deaths to the Warren Board of Health, Zigmont said Gillette reported its COVID-19 deaths to the Centers for Disease Control and Ohio Department of Health, as required. She said she was never told the deaths were supposed to be reported to the Warren Board of Health.

"We had no idea," Zigmont said.

Karri Carrico, a Gillette nurse and leader of the union that represents nurses and some other workers at the facility, said Todd Stein "went above and beyond in acquiring supplies and protective equipment. He prepared in every way for this eventuality," she said of a virus outbreak.

The facility had one staff virus case before December but had none among patients before December, Todd Stein said.

"We did everything we could, but just every day there were new cases popping up. We worked long hours," Carrico said.

"Staff started getting sick. The ones who were capable, they wanted to come to work and take care of the residents because it is like a family here," she said.

Todd Stein said he was paying as much as $81 per hour to nurses.

"These deaths were as devastating to us who work here as it was to the actual family," Carrico said. "We even lost one of our own, someone I've know for over 30 years and worked with. If there was anything else possible we could have done, we would have done it."

erunyan@tribtoday.com

Starting at /week.