I have rarely seen a more transparent attempt to generate 'hits' on this site. 'Hits' translate to advertising dollars.
Let's ask your question from another point of view: Does a collective bargaining agreement have legal standing, or is it just another piece of paper?
Common sense says that since the roads are in their worst shape in memory, thanks to an extraordinary winter, and since the condition of many of the county-maintained roads are unacceptable, times like this require unusual measures to make the roads passable. Language can be agreed upon where no full-time employee will lose his or her job to prison labor, and that prisoners will only be used in times of great need.
Instead of advocating compromise and reality, the Vindy chooses to stir the Union vs non-Union debate here. I'll guarantee this devolves into pro-union and anti-union by the end of the day.
Its not like the union is out there busting their butts to fill the potholes. I see a couple streets have been patched but that still leaves the vast majority effed. I think they should expand and use more inmates. Its good for everyone. The inmates get to do something productive and it saves the tax payers money and car repairs.
If the city or county needs more road workers for these projects they should hire from the pool of local unemployed law abiding citizens instead of giving the jobs to criminals.
Yes they should; it's a safety issue.
I'm all for giving jobs to the local unemployed but the problem is the union will have 3-4 guys watching 1 guy fill the hole. So in this case, inmates are the best alternative to get the work done since it doesn't seem to be getting done otherwise.
Great! Instead of repealing the 13th Amendment and restoring indentured servitude, why not teach prisoners a trade and let city workers do their jobs? it costs less than recidivism.
How about a compromise?Hire felons to work at Engineer's Office! Already have a start....http://www.vindy.com/news/2013/may/04...
Why don't you ask Sheriff Arpaio (Phoenix) how this would work? Their rate of recidivism is the lowest in the country. It's not about indentured servitude - they're C R I M I N A L S! They owe a debt to every law-abiding citizen and hard work may give them a sense of pride and a work ethic. For a city on the brink of bankruptcy it makes perfect sense.
The prisoners DO NOT Get PAID. YOU pay for them to be in jail. At least if they are filling pot-holes you are getting something for your money. How many millions does the Sheriff require to house and heat these criminals.
What is wrong with them giving labor to the county that must feed and shelter them?
"Inmates do not have the proper training on how to fix the roads properly"
It's called "on the job training". I give you a shovel and you fill the hole.
I wonder if richardlewis973 is one of those union guys we see standing around trying to figure out how they're going to fix the pothole while we, the stupid working fools aka taxpayers land in the potholes every day on our way to work... that is if you're anywhere to be seen.
Forgotten your password?