History of The Oakhill Case

More than 22 months after a Cuyahoga County grand jury unsealed an indictment in the Oakhill Renaissance Place criminal-corruption case, we’ve finally come to the trial.

The case centers on an alleged conspiracy between some Mahoning County officials and Anthony Cafaro Sr., a prominent businessman, to stop the 2007 relocation of a Mahoning County agency from a building owned by Cafaro’s company to the county-owned Oakhill.

Click here to read more

Who's Who in Oakhill

Filed by the state of Ohio against the following people and businesses, showing their purported involvement with other members of the enterprise.

John McNally

Mahoning County Commissioner 2005 - 2014

Was organizer and leader of the public officials.

Charges: Breached the sanctity of confidentiality to obstruct Mahoning County from purchasing a building by divulging material to Anthony Cafaro Sr. or his attorneys. Tampering with records, lying under oath in a lawsuit. Accepted money and services from Cafaro Sr. and/or Cafaro Co. in the course of his duties as county commissioner. Committed theft in office. Filed false ethics reports, and committed other crimes to conceal conduct. Recruited officials, Cafaro Sr. and others who provided benefits to Yavorcik to run for Mahoning County prosecutor so that, if elected, he could stop any investigation into wrongdoing committed by members of the enterprise.

Michael Sciortino

Mahoning County Auditor 2005 - 2015

Charges: Made false statements in legal proceedings. Accepted money and services from Cafaro Sr. and/or Cafaro Co. for performance of his duties as county auditor. Provided services and benefits to Yavorcik so that, if elected, he could stop any investigation into wrongdoing committed by members of the enterprise. Filed false ethics disclosure forms.

Martin Yavorcik

Independent candidate in Nov. 2008 Election for Mahoning County Prosecutor

Charges: Accepted benefits (money and services) from Lisa Antonini, Cafaro Sr., Sciortino, McNally, John Reardon and others so that if he was elected, he would not investigate or prosecute any members of the enterprise.

McNally and Sciortino Character Letters

Character letters to Judge Janet R. Burnside on behalf of John McNally IV and Michael Sciortino in regards to the Oakhill case.

Judge's Journal Entries for Yavorcik

Judge's journal entries in Oakhill case no. CR-14-585428-C, The State of Ohio vs. Martin Yavorcik.

Yavorcik Motion for Testimony

Case No. CR-585428-C: State of Ohio vs Martin E. Yavorcik. Motion for Grand Jury Testimony and Documents for the Oakhill case.

Motion to Ammend Indictment

State's motion to amend the indictment.

Oakhill secrecy hearing

The Vindicator and 21 WFMJ-TV argued that filings in the Oakhill Renaissance criminal conspiracy case should be made available to the public ...

Mayor McNally discusses Oakhill outcome

Video provided by WFMJ. Mayor Michael McNally discusses his plea deal in the Oakhill corruption case with reporters as he exits a ...

2muchtax posted in Martin Yavorcik has his law ...

Judge Burnside should be ashamed and disbarred. These 3 idiot muskateers got a slap on ...

suggest removal

NoBS posted in Martin Yavorcik has his law ...

Sorry, Dave, but that's not quite so. Yavorcik lives in a neighborhood where houses go ...

suggest removal

handymandave posted in Martin Yavorcik has his law ...

Yavorcik lost the ability to do what he presumably loved which was to practice law. ...

suggest removal

DontBanThisDrone posted in Martin Yavorcik has his law ...

He'll apply for reinstatement in a few years. And of course get it. (-:

suggest removal

2muchtax posted in Yavorcik gets 5 years of ...

The 3 muskateers Yarcovik, McNalley and Sorentino are all three crooked Cafaro lackeys, the other ...

suggest removal

Oakhill Timeline - FEBRUARY 29, 2016:

The trial is set to begin.

Oakhill Timeline - FEBRUARY 26, 2016:

McNally and Sciortino took plea agreements McNally accepted a plea to four misdemeanors: two counts of falsification and one count each of unlawful use of a telecommunications device and attempted unlawful influence of a public official. Sciortino took a deal to a felony count of having an unlawful interest in a public contract, originally tampering with records, as well as misdemeanors of falsification and receiving or soliciting improper compensation. He is also prohibited from holding a public office for seven years.

Oakhill Timeline - FEBRUARY 15, 2016:

Yavorcik provides a 24-page document from prosecutors given to him before his indictment outlining the prosecutors’ case against him.

Oakhill Timeline - FEBRUARY 12, 2016:

The judge agrees to let Yavorcik, an attorney since 1999, defend himself.

Oakhill Timeline - JANUARY 14, 2016:

At the request of Judge Burnside, prosecutors reduce the number of counts against the three defendants to 53. Prosecutors say it keeps the strongest charges in the indictment.

Oakhill Timeline - DECEMBER 1, 2015:

Defendants file their list of 68 potential witnesses.

Oakhill Timeline - OCTOBER 27, 2015:

Prosecutors file their list of 86 potential witnesses to testify in the case. The number is reduced to 53 on Jan. 22, 2016.

Oakhill Timeline - OCTOBER 16, 2015:

The first public pretrial hearing in the case includes the revelation that Youngstown political consultant Harry Strabala admitted he secretly recorded Mahoning Valley politicians.

Oakhill Timeline - JUNE 14, 2015:

Prosecutors indict Sciortino in Mahoning County on 25 felonies: 21 counts of unauthorized use of property - computer or telecommunication property - and 4 counts of theft in office. He is accused of illegally using government-owned computers and software more than 300 time to raise money for political purposes to keep him in office, and for directing three of his employees to assist him. He pleads not guilty.

Oakhill Timeline - JANUARY 8, 2015:

A 100-page “notice of intent to use evidence” is filed by prosecutors that provides further details on the alleged crimes committed by the defendants.

Oakhill Timeline - NOVEMBER 5, 2014:

Sciortino is defeated by Republican Ralph Meacham in a re-election bid. Sciortino’s term ends Feb. 23, 13 days before it was to officially end, with a three-member panel of retired judge remove him early from office. He spent those final days on paid suspension.

Oakhill Timeline - JUNE 11, 2014:

A 145-page bill of particulars is filed by prosecutors that outline the specific charges against the three defendants.

Oakhill Timeline - MAY 30, 2014:

The three defendants plead not guilty to the charges.

Oakhill Timeline - MAY 14, 2014:

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine and Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Timothy McGinty announced a 83-count indictment against Youngstown Mayor John A. McNally, then-Mahoning County Auditor Michael Sciortino and attorney Marty Yavorcik. The charges include engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity, bribery, perjury, conspiracy, money laundering and tampering with records.

Oakhill Timeline - JULY 11, 2011:

A visiting judge dismisses a 73-count indictment without prejudice, meaning the charges could be refiled later. The case was dismissed by prosecutors because of their inability to obtain tape recordings from the FBI and provide them to the defense making it impossible to proceed.

Oakhill Timeline - JULY 29, 2010:

The grand jury returns a 73-count indictment charging seven people and three organizations with multiple felony and misdemeanor charges related to the relocation of the county’s Job and Family Services offices from Garland Plaza to Oakhill Renaissance Place.

Oakhill Timeline - FEBRUARY-JULY 2010:

A Mahoning County grand jury hears testimony and examines documents on Oakhill in at least 12 sessions with the special prosecutors, concluding its work this week. The grand jury, which was scheduled for a four-month session ending April 30, was extended twice at the request of the special prosecutors, but the county’s common pleas judges said the extension ending this week would be the final extension.

Oakhill Timeline - DECEMBER 2008:

The county moves its Veterans’ Service Commission from its Southside Annex to Oakhill.

Oakhill Timeline - NOVEMBER 2008:

At the request of Mahoning County Prosecutor Paul J. Gains, the county common pleas judges appoint Dennis P. Will and Paul M. Nick as special prosecutors to probe potential criminal conflict of interest related to the purchase of Oakhill.

Oakhill Timeline - JULY 2006:

The County buys Oakhill in U.S. Bankruptcy Court and keeps the city health department and coroner’s office there, but assumes responsibility for more than $900,000 worth of mortgages and liens, including a $430,000 Ohio Department of Development loan to SCDC and a real estate tax bill of about $400,000.


HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2016 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes