Tuesday, October 3, 2017
Developer Dominic Marchionda and affiliated businesses were indicted today on 105 criminal counts related to alleged corrupt activity, theft, and money laundering related to three development projects in the city.
By David Skolnick
Dominic Marchionda, prominent downtown property developer, and his affiliated businesses are accused in a 105-count indictment of a scheme “to funnel government money” to himself through various companies “to live his lavish lifestyle and enrich himself.”
DOWNLOAD: Marchionda indictment documents
The 73-page indictment, unsealed Monday by a Mahoning County grand jury, also alleges an unnamed city official – “John Doe 8” – helped Marchionda in exchange for a $25,000 bribe in spring 2009.
A source with knowledge of the lengthy investigation into Marchionda said the city official is Finance Director David Bozanich. There also are enough hints in the indictment that point to Bozanich, including a line that states to ensure a Marchionda project obtains city approval, the $25,000 is needed to “take care of Dave.”
Bozanich, who couldn’t be reached Monday by The Vindicator to comment, hasn’t been charged, and Mayor John A. McNally said he has no plans to fire or discipline the finance director.
A source said authorities are investigating Bozanich for a possible indictment.
Bozanich had search warrants executed on his house and the residence of his girlfriend, where he was living, on July 6.
Also, on the same day as Bozanich’s raid, investigators seized money and computer equipment from the home and law office of Atty. Stephen Garea as part of this investigation. Garea served as Marchionda’s attorney on the deals with the city. He hasn’t been indicted.
Authorities seized records March 16 from Marchionda’s NYO Property Group offices in downtown Youngstown and at his Poland home on Via Atillio.
Dan Tierney, an Ohio Attorney General’s Office spokesman, said the investigation is ongoing and declined to comment on any future indictments.
The investigation accuses Marchionda, 58, of misusing money obtained from the city as well as the state and federal governments for the Flats at Wick student housing complex and projects to turn the Erie Terminal Place and Wick Towers into downtown apartments.
The crimes are alleged in the indictment to have occurred between May 1, 2009, and Jan. 1, 2016.
John F. McCaffrey, Marchionda’s attorney, said, “The state alleges that Marchionda’s development success was accomplished through theft and deceit. It refers to his redevelopment projects and efforts as a ‘Ponzi scheme.’ Mr. Marchionda rejects the state’s characterization and will defend his years of development work with evidence in a court of law.”
McCaffrey added: “Dominic Marchionda believes in the rebirth of downtown Youngstown. He has taken dilapidated, abandoned buildings and breathed new life into them. He has renovated, rehabilitated and refurbished long-forgotten downtown properties for modern-day use. He risked a great deal, personally and professional, in pursuing his dream for Youngstown.”
The case was investigated by the Ohio Auditor of State’s Public Integrity Assurance Team with the assistance of the county sheriff’s department. The Ohio Attorney General’s Office is serving as special assistant prosecutor with the county in this case.
Marchionda was indicted on these criminal counts:
One count of engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity
Four counts of aggravated theft
65 counts of money laundering
15 counts of tampering with records
Eight counts of telecommunications fraud
Five counts of receiving stolen property
One count of falsification
One count of attempted grand theft
One count of attempted securing writing by deception
One count of theft
Also indicted Monday were Marchionda-run companies Rubino Construction Inc., U.S. Campus Suites LLC, Erie Terminal Place LLC, Wick Properties LLC, and Villas di Tuscany LLC.
Marchionda and the companies are scheduled to be arraigned Oct. 10 in common pleas court.
“Allegations such as those contained in this indictment must be treated seriously and investigated thoroughly. This investigation and prosecution is a collaborative effort among several offices, and I want to thank the Auditor of State and officials in Mahoning County for their efforts,” said Attorney General Mike DeWine.
“What our investigators found is deeply disturbing,” Auditor Dave Yost said. “Our team has worked this investigation for more than two years. They were tenacious and tireless in seeking justice, and there is more to come.”
The indictment alleges Marchionda improperly spent grants received from Youngstown from its water and wastewater funds and loans from the city in addition to money from the state and federal to develop the projects.
He is accused of improperly spending at least $600,000 from city funds on personal items.
“Marchionda used city of Youngstown monies beyond the express or implied consent to pay personal debt, to pay cost[s] unrelated to the purpose for which the funds were provided to Marchionda and in doing so provided false billing records to city of Youngstown officials,” the indictment reads.
In the case of Flats at Wick, U.S. Campus Suites LLC, a company controlled by Marchionda, received $1.2 million from the city’s water and wastewater funds and then sent $1 million back to the city to buy a fire station property on Madison Avenue on the North Side for the project.
Once the city received the $1 million, it was “placed into the general fund of the city of Youngstown in violation of Ohio law under the direction of David Bozanich,” the indictment reads.
The indictment states Marchionda took the remaining $200,000 – the difference between the $1.2 million grant and the $1 million he gave back to the city – and transferred $70,000 to a company he owned and then transferred funds to himself to pay for “personal expenses like his medical expenses, the Poland Swim Club, personal bounced-checks fees, the Holy Family Facilities fund, real-estate taxes, dental bills and other personal bills, person[al] debt and investment purposes. The funds were not spent on water or sewer related issues.”
McNally said city council reviewed and approved the fire station deal in 2009, and the board of control – the mayor, law director and finance director – determined it to be appropriate.
The city also loaned $2 million to U.S. Campus Suites that was to be solely used for the project. But the indictment contends Marchionda used it “for personal purposes and/or uses not permitted by the loan agreement with the city of Youngstown. That trend continued with float loans received by Erie Terminal Place LLC and Wick Properties LLC when each company received its float loan money. Typically, monies were deposited into the account of [the companies] then transferred by phone call, wire or email by Dominic Marchionda to Rubino Construction Inc., who then distributed funds for lawful purposes and unlawful purposes transferring hundreds of thousands of dollars to Dominic Marchionda for him to spend on personal items.”
The city in 2011 gave $350,000 in water and wastewater funds to a company owned by Marchionda that developed Erie Terminal and then $220,000 two years later for improvement work at that property.
Also, $500,000 in water and wastewater funds went to a company owned by Marchionda in 2015 for the Wick project.
Among the numerous allegations against Marchionda is he falsified payroll records for the Wick project to secure a $5 million state-energy loan.
A Marchionda company is developing a DoubleTree by Hilton hotel at the downtown Stambaugh Building that is slated to open in March.
A theft count in the indictment accuses Wick Properties LLC of using between $7,500 and $150,000 in city funds that was supposed to go to Wick Towers for the hotel project.
“We’ll be reviewing each of the [hotel] transactions to make sure each disbursement was spent properly,” McNally said. “We’re hopeful the hotel project will continue. We’ll be reviewing each of the agreements on the project.”
The indictment also accuses Marchionda of theft related to his improperly taking between $1,000 and $7,500 from the Rich Center for Autism.