facebooktwitterRSS
- Advertisement -
  • Most Commentedmost commented up
  • Most Emailedmost emailed up
  • Popularmost popular up
- Advertisement -
 

« News Home

Letters: GOP leader criticizes Vindicator; Tressel deserves YSU presidency; As for Dunn, let buyer beware



Published: Sun, February 23, 2014 @ 12:00 a.m.

Vindicator should choose to be positive force in Valley

Bertram de Souza’s rant against the Mahoning County GOP for failing to offer a full slate of candidates seems a little strange considering the Mahoning County Democrats also failed to offer a full slate of candidates. The GOP’s failure earned a call for my resignation; the Democrat’s failure was somehow overlooked.

Both parties have an obligation to encourage honest, credible political competition, but that is easier said than done when Republicans are outnumbered by Democrats 5 to 1. In spite of the odds and a sometimes hostile environment, it’s important that we continue our efforts to attract opposition candidates.

When we were successful in recruiting a candidate, Bill Reese for county auditor in this case, de Souza was quick to suggest that our offering was lacking for not having “countywide political credentials.”

Where does de Souza expect candidates to come from? It’s pretty common for candidates to step up from one level to the next, and Bill Reese is a well respected, two-term Canfield Township trustee. The community would be better served by encouraging challengers, rather than minimizing them.

As for Judge Mark Belinky, it’s unfortunate the raid on his office came after the filing deadline. Because of that timing, Valley citizens were denied an important piece of information that might have attracted more interest in the race. It must be noted that Judge Belinky received a glowing endorsement from The Vindicator four years ago, when they could have backed his Republican opponent, Judge Scott Hunter.

The Vindicator is correct in noting there is no Republican candidate for probate court, at least not yet. However, all the filing deadlines have not yet passed, and our efforts to recruit a candidate continue.

My bigger disappointment is really with The Vindicator, not de Souza, who was writing commentary. This past Dec. 2, I sent a press release to The Vindicator asking for help to alert the public about upcoming election opportunities for Republicans and Democrats. I focused on county, state legislative and precinct races. The press release and the help it might have provided were ignored.

The Vindicator could have played a better role by helping to alert citizens to political opportunities rather than complaining after the first deadline had passed.

This community needs a strong newspaper. Todd Franko noted in his Jan. 26 column that “Good reporting, newspapering and journalism is like good security lighting. It shines light on things you probably need to see.”

The Vindicator spent three days covering a $17,000 budget increase for raises at the board of elections. What about the $1.7 million in raises that were granted in Mahoning County last year? The light wasn’t shining as bright.

The Vindicator can be a positive force for change; it can also be part of the problem.

Mark Munroe, Boardman

Munroe is chairman of the Mahoning County Republican Party.

As president, Tressel would bring many assets to Youngstown State

I was upset with YSU President Randy Dunn “bailing” on us and think the timing was bad for it was on a day when potential YSU students and their parents were at the WATTS Center for an informational gathering about YSU.

I hope Dr. Dunn’s primary reason for leaving was not the additional $55,000. If it was, I feel that he should have honored his commitment. Sometimes, things change for the best, in this case, another chance to have someone who has put the YSU logo on the map to be our next YSU president.

Certainly, YSU has made national news with its engineering department being named one of the best in its category. The university also has been mentioned in conjunction with Youngstown’s additive-engineering process. The business and education departments, among others, have also attained national attention.

Having Jim Tressel as the next president is a win-win situation. As I said above:

He has put YSU on the map with his record as the football coach.

No one has the respect and connection with the surrounding YSU business community that Mr. Tressel enjoys.

He definitely can promote the tie between downtown Youngstown and YSU.

I think his name recognition will help to reverse YSU’s declining enrollment.

He would definitely be a positive for all YSU athletics. His name would help recruit more local talent to all programs.

He is a great motivator. As I told my family and friends when he interviewed for the OSU job , once they hear him talk, he is gone from YSU. This attribute could only help in YSU contract negotiations with unions and teaching staff.

I hope that the YSU community (students and staff at YSU, businesses, the city of Youngstown, etc.) will, for once, step up and draft Tressel for YSU’s next president.

Myron S. Mondora Jr., Canfield

As for Dunn, let the buyer beware

On March 15, 2013, and again on May 10, 2013, the Murray State Board of Regents voted 7-4 to let Randy Dunn’s contract expire instead of renewing it. In other words, Murray State said that they did not want him.

The regents’ reasoning was based on his continued public search for another job coupled with what they viewed as his poor job performance. Specifically, Murray State’s academic standing had fallen, and enrollment had dropped under Dunn’s leadership.

However, almost simultaneous with those no-confidence votes, YSU pursued him to be its next president. Without a job, Randy Dunn gladly accepted YSU’s generous offer. He has been president at YSU for less than a year, but the same issues that dogged him at Murray State have followed him here. Still, he has somehow managed to get a “better job” in his home state.

Apparently Dunn has been on a perpetual job search since 2010, stopping by YSU for salary, health care, and lodging to aid in his transition from Murray State to Southern Illinois University.

To YSU, its search committee, and board of trustees, I ask them to open their eyes next time they hire a president.

To SIU, I say thank you for taking an unethical, itinerant, self-promoting individual from us. Let the buyer beware.

David Padgett, Canfield

Dunn joins a long list of traitors

Randy Dunn abandoned YSU for a unique opportunity. A unique opportunity for whom? He gave his word. He bested his opponents for the YSU president’s job. As soon as he was offered more money in the town he lived in for years, his self-interest trumped his promises to the YSU community.

Was loyalty and a commitment to one’s word ever in our history predominant in a person’s character? I think of other examples of individuals with “unique opportunities”: Art Modell, LeBron James, Benedict Arnold, and all the others that left for their own “unique opportunities.”

Maybe we should promote from within instead of spending $110,000 to search for a leader with no more loyalty than a pole dancer. (The students and their parents pay this). Maybe we should look for new trustees who aren’t taken in by a “good personality” and who are OK with “well he has a unique opportunity.”

Maybe we should revamp our education system to make honor and loyalty our first priority rather than technical skills. Maybe then it will even catch on to our political and business leaders who would find diverting tax dollars from hurricane relief or promoting business harmful to consumers and our environment as not a unique opportunity for personal gain but repugnant to the values we should have. Yeah right.

Phillip S. Arbie, Warren


Comments

1Knightcap(700 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

"1.7 million in raises that were granted in Mahoning County last year" WTF? And these common thieves want you take money from your wallet to support their greed! Vote no.

Suggest removal:

2formerdemliberal(182 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

Good to see Mark Munroe emerge from his foxhole. Perhaps his facts about a 5-1 Democratic majority are based upon party affiliation documented on voter registration forms. However, Republican presidential candidates have received over 35% of the area vote in the last two presidential elections (McCain 36% in 2008, Romney 35.5% in 2012 or 41,000-45,000 Mahoning County Republican votes).

The factual disparity may come from Republican voters (including myself) who remain registered Democrats to vote in Democratic contested elections that contain candidates fighting against the party machine during the primary season, rather than the typical single candidate on the Republican side.

Nowhere in his response can I find a single positive reason to vote for a Republican to change local government operations. Individual candidates should discuss the details of their policies directly with the voters. However, the supposed leader of his party in the county can only come up with excuses why Republicans can't win elections in Mahoning County, rather than why they should.

How about defining Republican philosophy for those running for office in Mahoning County?

Some suggestions (took me 20 minutes to compile this list):
1. No new sales taxes. Republicans will provide the best possible services within their budgets to the community just like businesses and households.
2. Government hirings based upon qualifications, not political connections.
3. Use of activity-based performance standards to assess employee productivity
4. Administrative raises based on substantiated data, not the buddy system (including the board of elections).
5. Any department surpluses achieved through improved productivity distributed equally as department bonuses and into a rainy day fund
6. Outsourcing various government functions to the private sector
7. Gradually reducing public employee union pension costs by not replacing retiring employees
8. Aggressively promoting energy development in the area while involving educated environmentalists in drilling oversight.
9. Stimulating the economy with more private sector participation in YSU technology center, STEM, and business incubator resources.

These suggestions would scare the hell out of union county employees, political leeches, and be ridiculed by Democratic candidates as anti-middle class, anti-union, and destroying basic public services. So what? County Republican candidates are losing anyway.

The overall mission of every Republican candidate should reflect a positive image of putting more money in taxpayers pockets, rather than promoting government cronyism.

Unfortunately, Mr. Munroe has decided to waste readers time with his sour grapes letter blaming everyone but himself for the lack of success of his party in local and national elections.

Want a little cheese with that whine, Mr. Munroe? Maybe you should work with your pal Bruce Zoldan and his ponies at the racino.

Suggest removal:

3questionreality(266 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

Most notable of Munroe's remarks is this: "Todd Franko noted in his Jan. 26 column that “Good reporting, newspapering and journalism is like good security lighting. It shines light on things you probably need to see.”

There is much to see out there but the Vindy is quite selective. As an example:

MINUTES OF MEETING HELD DECEMBER 9, 2013
RESOLUTION 13-12-09-11:

Motion was made by Mr. Costello to approve the salary increase of Road Superintendent Larry Wilson according to the terms and conditions set forth in the attached Memorandum of Understanding, as attached to these minutes.
Seconded by Mr. Calhoun.

http://boardmantwp.com/wp-content/upl...

Munroe points out that "The Vindicator spent three days covering a $17,000 budget increase for raises at the board of elections." and asks, "What about......?" That "what about" list could be very long. Where's the light?

Suggest removal:

4author50(1121 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

Mark Munroe and Tracy Winbush are the so called leaders of the Republican Party (in name only) in Mahoning County. They are so bad they make David Betras look good.

Munroe with an assist from David Myhal using Clarence Smith's money destroyed a great slate of young republicans who ran a full slate of candidates in 2000 WITHOUT the help of the aforementioned who actually stabbed all the candidates (except Paul Sarasic Myhal's poly-sci prof) in the back because all the candidates that year campaigned to defeat the sales tax and live by Peat-Marwick. Munroe is such a bad Chairperson that he can't even field a full slate of precinct people in reliable Poland Village.

Suggest removal:

5dontbeafool(912 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

If you don't like the Vindy, don't read it eivo. For a sucky paper, you sure spend a lot of time on its website. And if you don't like where you live......MOVE.

Suggest removal:

6Kernaloftruth(86 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

I don't think Eivo said he doesn't like where he lives, rather no person in their right mind would run as a Republican here because the electorate has fooled themselves into thinking the Democrats are best for representing them, even when they aren't.

That said, Belinky's endorsement is only the tip of the iceberg. How many other felons has this paper given glowing reviews to the last 30 years?

Suggest removal:

7evio(43 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

@Kernal,
And this is how you feel about living here: "I'm ashamed to say I come from an area where our elected representative screwed so many people because he drank the healthcare Kool Aid."

Suggest removal:

8Kernaloftruth(86 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

Well, obviously you cannot differentiate between "this area sucks" and "our area is represented by bad leadership". How I feel about who represents us doesn't exactly translate to how I feel about Youngstown in general.

I shouldn't have to "move" as you suggest because I feel this area could benefit from better leadership and because I criticize our bad choices of leadership and the bad choices this particular paper has made over the years.

Sorry friend, you don't get to tell me how I feel about things. Welcome to Youngstown.

Suggest removal:

9Kernaloftruth(86 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

The fact the comment you brought up came from November of last year shows you had to really go through my posts to find one that may have had a negative slant to things. I'd consider myself honored that you went to such lengths to find a post that doesn't quite fit your argument.

Suggest removal:

10evio(43 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

Just google ashamed, kernaloftruth and up it comes. Less than 1 second. Not much lengths.

"I'm ashamed to say I'm from an area", expresses a feeling. You told the world how you feel about Youngstown.

Suggest removal:

11evio(43 comments)posted 7 months, 1 week ago

@Kernal,

Who said "This area sucks"? Someone on this thread?

Suggest removal:

12GoPens(397 comments)posted 7 months ago

Decided to give the billionaire Koch brothers even more money eivo? You're dumber than I thought if that's possible.

Suggest removal:

13GoPens(397 comments)posted 7 months ago

The only prosperity the Koch Brothers care about is their own, and you bought it hook, line and sinker. It makes me sick that they take advantage of and take money from the mentally challenged.

"Our latest ad"? Were you there producing it?

Suggest removal:


News
Opinion
Entertainment
Sports
Marketplace
Classifieds
Records
Discussions
Community
Help
Forms
Neighbors

HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2014 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes | Pittsburgh International Airport