facebooktwitterRSS
- Advertisement -
  • Most Commentedmost commented up
  • Most Emailedmost emailed up
  • Popularmost popular up
- Advertisement -
 

« News Home

Ohio will soon authorize fracking wastewater pools



Published: Sun, October 6, 2013 @ 12:05 a.m.

Football field-sized ponds to recycle waste

By Jamison Cocklin

jcocklin@vindy.com

youngstown

Ohio regulators will soon approve and permit large, exposed centralized impoundments that hold fracking flowback water.

These are used widely by oil and gas companies in other states to recycle the waste and serve multiple wells near one another .

The impoundments, or pits, which sometimes exceed the size of a football field and can hold millions of gallons of water, are now banned in Ohio.

But they’ve proved a useful asset to companies operating in other states such as Pennsylvania and West Virginia. The impoundments serve as water-transfer stations for multiple wells nearby, greatly reducing the amount of truck traffic and the water necessary to drill and frack those wells.

Existing Ohio regulations permit use of lined impoundments that hold freshwater for drilling. Flowback, or fracking wastewater, however, must be stored above ground in covered steel tanks before disposal or reuse.

But effective Jan. 1, the centralized impoundment pools will be authorized by the Ohio Department of Natural Resources as part of a regulatory change state legislators made in the biennial budget bill signed in June.

Changes to the law likely came after input from the industry. Operators consider centralized impoundments a key to further developing the Utica Shale play.

“These facilities are critical in the recycling and reuse process and help to reduce truck traffic and the need for impoundments for individual well sites,” said Matt Pitzarella, a spokesman for Texas-based Range Resources, which does not hold acreage in Ohio, but is the largest operator of impoundments in Pennsylvania, where it has extensive operations. “Impoundments have reduced tens of thousands of truck loads in Pennsylvania and have allowed companies to utilize larger sources of water like the Ohio River.”

A shale well typically requires between 1 million and 8 million gallons of water to complete. Water from the wells generally comes from nearby, either from a public water supply, pond or lake. Trucks and pipelines are required to carry the resource to the drilling site.

Last month, at an oil and gas conference in Youngstown, Harry Schurr, general manager of Utica operations for Pennsylvania-based Consol Energy, said central impoundments in Ohio would significantly aid further development here and help meet the demand for water in southern parts of the state where it’s not as abundant.

Schurr said it also would help Consol, which has drilled about 215 wells in Pennsylvania and Ohio, to recycle the vast amount of water it requires for its operations. He added that the company hoped ODNR might soon approve the impoundments and believed it would do so based on interactions the company has had with regulators.

On Wednesday, Consol spokeswoman Lynn Seay wrote in an email that “We understand the ODNR is currently reviewing a regulatory approach to allowing the use of centralized impoundments, and we look forward to that possibility.”

Mark Bruce, an ODNR spokesman, said the agency is developing rules “that will clearly define standards regarding the construction, length of use, design and other factors” of impoundments.

The move is likely to rankle oil and gas industry opponents, who three years into the play claim the state has become a dumping ground for wastewater. They’ve taken aim at Ohio’s injection wells, where the most recent ODNR data shows that 14.2 million barrels of fluid were disposed of underground in 2012.

The centralized impoundments, which are roughly 200 feet wide and 300 feet long, or larger, are likely to draw the attention of critics.

But engineers inside and outside the industry claim that when the pits are designed and built correctly, they are entirely safe.

Fracking waste includes salt, dissolved solids and light radioactive and toxic metals from its contact with underground rocks. Chemicals added to the mixture contain volatile organic compounds, such as benzene and toulene.

Pitzarella said misconceptions about the impoundments remain, despite safeguards and a closed-loop system.

After use at a well site, the water is conditioned and some salt and dissolved solids remain. It is then transported and stored at an impoundment until its next use when it is mixed with freshwater for drilling.

The mixture is sometimes circulated to prevent bacteria growth. Layers of synthetic materials form a double- lined seal and a catch basin with a leak detection system installed between those layers. Other measures, such as additional leak detection and ground water monitoring wells help operators oversee any problems.

John Quaranta, an assistant professor of civil and environmental engineering at West Virginia University, said if the impoundments are constructed properly, they pose no hazards.

But a study he led for legislators and the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection last year found that isn’t always the case.

In an examination of 15 well sites in the state, Quaranta and other WVU researchers found that some pits were poorly constructed, while the state inspectors sent to examine the sites had little or no structural knowledge of impoundments. Though netting is often placed above the impoundments to keep wildlife out, researchers also found garbage in some pits.

“The problems identified do constitute a real hazard and present risk if allowed to progress,” the study’s authors wrote. “But all problems that were observed in the field could be corrected.”

The impoundments have led to fierce debate in other states, where some residents have complained about odors and what has seemed like the permanency of the pits, which are only supposed to be temporary and reclaimed after drilling.

Quaranta said it’s imperative that Ohio regulators provide strict guidelines on the construction, permitting and reclamation of impoundments when they’re authorized in the state.

He said operators have tried to keep the pits open in some instances and get them repermitted for future use, which he advised against in his report.

Bruce said regulators are in the process of determining how long the impoundments can remain in operation. He added they will be temporary, but a time line hasn’t yet been determined.

“ODNR is concentrating the necessary resources to write and develop these rules understanding that effective, strong and clear regulations provide the maximum protection of human health, safety and the environment, while also allowing for the responsible development of Ohio’s natural resources,” he said in an email.


Comments

1UticaShale(850 comments)posted 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Has the potential for aquaculture been a part of the ODNR study? Or should we just keep letting third world countries farm our seafood without regulation?

Suggest removal:

2Think121(51 comments)posted 9 months, 2 weeks ago

There is absolute prrof that the flowback water is radioactive and has contaminated in PA. One stream is now a radioactive site for at least the next 1600 years. Why on earth would Ohio allow this as well as the trucks hauling to and from these ponds? Why on earth would any trucker want any part of transporting this?

Suggest removal:

3RustOnMyBelt(112 comments)posted 9 months, 2 weeks ago

"Wormwood". Rev.8:10-11

Suggest removal:

4southsidedave(4777 comments)posted 9 months, 2 weeks ago

...and the money continues to roll in, but at what cost to our health?

Suggest removal:

5JoeFromHubbard(974 comments)posted 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Radioactive?

The sun is radioactive. Let's get the EPA busy on solar radiation and give them something meaningful to do.

The impoundment pool will be a productive tool for the fracking industry and should be deployed as needed to reduce costs.

Suggest removal:

6hunky(38 comments)posted 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Yes. It's just too good to be true. Say it leaks for some reason. How big of a fight will it be to get them to admit their wrong and clean it up quickly? Oh, if only the EPA couldn't be bought, but lo, our watchdog is eating their steak.

Suggest removal:

7Chester05(5 comments)posted 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Obviously nobody is ever going to stop the machine that is natural gas companies. But you know who won't be living anywhere near any of these ponds... this guy. It's your backyard, do with it as you please. I'll be the one shaking my head 10-15 years later.

Suggest removal:

8JakeJ(4 comments)posted 9 months, 2 weeks ago

I guess the Ohio legislature has been asleep at the well! There are now workers coming forward to warn people of the hazards of this flow back fluid and the dangers of just moving it. Storing it in open pits is insane. If you don't believe it, go to PA and see for yourself. marcellus-shale.us is a good place to see the frack pitts in PA. Also check out the latest news on radioactivity found in the PA rivers which is the drinking water supply for millions of people. We won't be satisfied until every last drop of water has been contaminated and the air so toxic we will all need to live in a bubble! http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/na...

Suggest removal:

9Think121(51 comments)posted 9 months ago

Some of the drill, baby, drill crowd just crack me up. You are all pro-drilling until the thought of having an impoundment pond is slated for your back yard. You make fun of the antis and call them names and insult them on a daily basis. You even go so far as to lie and insist they are well-funded, when nothing could be further from the truth.

Enter impoundment pond issues, especially after all the findings of radiactivity in waste water in PA and now you don't want them. Just view the Go Marcellus website and see the pro-drillers whining away about them. Rather than admit you were wrong on some issues, you are gathering forces to call the Gov and other lawmakers. Ohio has become the toilet of America for drilling wastes and you are just waking up to it. Those bonuses and royalties won't mean diddly when every drop of water in Ohio is polluted and rendered unusable from gas drilling and the associated waste. Maybe those antis were right from the beginning. Maybe you ought to stand up with them from time to time and help them stop the infrastructure and processing plants before you all glow in the dark.

Suggest removal:


News
Opinion
Entertainment
Sports
Marketplace
Classifieds
Records
Discussions
Community
Help
Forms
Neighbors

HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2014 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes | Pittsburgh International Airport