- Advertisement -
  • Most Commentedmost commented up
  • Most Emailedmost emailed up
  • Popularmost popular up
- Advertisement -

« News Home

Youngstown schools get bad news regarding finances

Published: Tue, January 22, 2013 @ 12:00 a.m.

It took one front-page headline to replace the optimism we voiced a couple of weeks ago about the Youngstown City School District with a growing sense of pessimism. The state-declared economic emergency that the district shed in 2011 after several years of fiscal commission governance could well be resurrected if the urban district does not get a handle on its five-year budget. As of today, things don’t look good for the academically and fiscally challenged system.

Here’s the headline that is the cause of our concern: “Schools’ deficit projected at $48 million/Hathorn proposes cuts to improve five-year forecast,” To be sure, we did a double-take when we saw the words “$48M.”

What happened to Ohio State Auditor David Yost’s positive outlook when he announced in March 2011 that the Youngstown schools system was being released from fiscal emergency?

Here’s what Yost said in a written statement: “Youngstown City Schools are leaner today than when they came into fiscal emergency in 2006. My office is proud to play a role in helping the school district skinny down and become financially healthy — and even prouder of what the district has done to accomplish it. This is a great day for Youngstown students.”

But today, the district’s future is bleak, forcing Superintendent Connie Hathorn and the board of education to come up with a plan to close the projected $48 million operating budget hole over the next four years.

While we believe that Dr. Hathorn and board members recognize that the district’s back is against the wall, we aren’t entirely confident that they have the wherewithal to tackle such an enormous challenge.

Help needed

Thus, we would urge Auditor Yost to send in his staffers who have spent years working on Youngstown’s finances to help the superintendent and the board chart a course through the choppy waters.

We seek the state’s involvement reluctantly. The return of auditors from Yost’s office could be viewed as an admission that local school officials lack the ability to deal with the fiscal challenges.

But that would be an unfair characterization of what’s going on.

Of the $48 million projected revenue shortfall, $40 million is being blamed on the loss of students to community schools, vouchers and open enrollment in adjoining school districts.

That is not good news.

If the Youngstown district is still losing a sizable number of students after the reorganization of the schools and the adoption of an academic recovery plan — the system is under state-mandated academic watch — the question must be asked: Is there anything that can be done to stop the exodus.

Superintendent Hathorn thinks so, but when he met with members of the state Academic Distress Commission, it appeared that he has an uphill battle winning them over. Hathorn detailed $8 million worth of savings by 2017, which prompted commissioner Michael Garvey, a prominent Mahoning Valley businessman, to ask, “What are you going to do for the other $40 million?”

What, indeed. Can a troubled urban school district survive when students continue to leave in droves even when the academic changes that have been implemented have received rave reviews from the Ohio Department of Education and other independent organizations?

The ODE has warned the Youngstown district that a takeover is possible if it fails to shows marked improvement in the state report card this year.

The ticking of the clock just got louder.


1nipsy(161 comments)posted 3 years, 6 months ago

Well, this is what we are going to get with open enrollment,Charter Schools and vouchers. The end of inner-city schools. Those that can get out are fleeing and those that can't are stuck in a never ending death spiral of a school, receiving a below standard education.

Suggest removal:

2One_Who_Stayed(240 comments)posted 3 years, 6 months ago

Well, I can tell you this: They are not going to Canfield, Boardman, Poland, Campbell or Springfield (all systems that ring the city of Youngstown except for Springfield). These systems are clearly petrified of letting ghetto kids into their school system. In the entire state of Ohio there are 5 closed enrollment school systems and they are it.

And please tell me - Oh state level wise ones - what exactly will you do "when" you do take over the Youngstown City Schools? How exactly will you fix this exodus? Simply tell them they must stay put? I think we should simply let them take it over now - I would love to see what steps they would take that no one else has thought of. The state should put-up or shut up when it comes to problems that I don't believe they can fix either.

Suggest removal:

3uselesseater(229 comments)posted 3 years, 6 months ago

Where again is the Youngstown City Schools proposed budget for 2012 or 2013? Anyone able to find it?

I see one document I am reading with an operating budget of $103 million of the city schools -- called 2011-2012 "General Fund Budget" and was a proposed number.

In fiscal year 2008, salaries consumed over $50 million of the school budget according to this document and were to be reduced to over $40 million in subsequent years.

Another $20 million each year was labeled "Fringe Benefits". Meaning employees are gobbling up $60-70 million of the total budget pie.

The document slams charter and other voucher schools as:
"... generally provide no better education".

Yeah, as if we believe that fiction.

Humorously, this document showed a yearly increasing Cash Balance reaching nearly $15 million in FY12.

In 2011, according to this document there was enrollment in Ytown schools of 6055. That is a falling number from 8551 in 2006.

If we talk the $104 million and divide it by 6055 students we get $17,175 per student.

Contrast this to the rates cost of enrollment 2011-12 at YSU, which are inclusive of room and board:

$15,551 for in-state
$15,761 for Western PA
$18,378 for regional service area
$21,508 for out of state and international students

Suggest removal:

4maxborenstein(27 comments)posted 3 years, 6 months ago

A 1% school district income tax should be placed on the ballot. If they let the city income tax get to 2.75%, then they may as well go for the gusto. The liberals won't believe that 3.75% combined local income tax is too high. In some California communities, 8% local tax is the norm.

Suggest removal:


HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2016 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes