Clinton’s critics are quacks

If only the people intent on dissecting Hillary Clinton’s blood clot would channel that energy in more productive ways.

There’s been quite a bit of sniping since it was announced in mid-December that a concussion would prevent Secretary of State Clinton from testifying as scheduled before congressional committees examining security failures that led to the deaths of four Americans in Benghazi, including U.S. Ambassador to Libya Christopher Stevens.

Official word initially was that Clinton had a stomach ailment, then that she had fainted at home from dehydration and hit her head, which resulted in a concussion. Then last Sunday she was admitted to the hospital for treatment of a blood clot in her head.

Before Clinton’s doctors found the clot, some of her detractors were using their utter lack of medical expertise to diagnose “Benghazi flu,” “diplomatic illness,” “acute Benghazi allergy” and other supposedly fake maladies that showed “impeccable timing” designed to extricate her from having to publicly take responsibility for a fiasco that she had already publicly taken responsibility for.


The bald meanness touched off back-and-forth about who was nastier or more off-base, the doubters or those who jumped on them for their rush to skepticism.

Those on the political left and right accused each other of politicizing the poor woman’s illness.

Some political conservatives went at each other: At, Kathleen Parker called attacks on Clinton’s character “cruel and unfair.” Mona Charen shot back on the blog “The Corner” that it was all because of “Clinton’s flamboyant history of lying.”

“Concussiongate” became a Twitter hashtag.

But this really isn’t like past scandal-gates with which Clinton’s been associated. A traumatic head injury isn’t a policy position.

When I heard about Clinton’s concussion, it seemed perfectly plausible that a 65-year-old woman who’d been vomiting because of a stomach virus could get dizzy, pass out and hurt her herself, even without immediately recognizing the severity of the damage.

The federal Centers for Disease Control reports that falls cause half the traumatic brain injuries among children aged 0 to 14 and 61 percent of those injuries in adults 65 and older. (

When I heard she had a blood clot, too, I immediately recalled December 1993. That’s when my father, then 62, fell in the bathroom at home and hit his head. He didn’t feel well after that and went to his regular physician, who diagnosed a sinus infection.

No one who saw my father daily (I was living in Washington, D.C., at the time) recognized that changes in his personality signaled something more serious. When my younger sister came from Houston for Christmas and realized that he wasn’t making sense, she insisted he go to the hospital. Surgery for a subdural hematoma, a collection of blood on the brain surface, almost certainly saved his life that Christmas. It was a frightening time, but we were blessed. He celebrated his 81st birthday in November.

Sinus thrombosis

Clinton was diagnosed with a less-common condition, a transverse sinus thrombosis, which is a clot behind the ear in a major vein that drains blood from the brain. She didn’t need surgery but instead was put on anti-coagulants to help dissolve the clot, according to news reports.

The public is still entitled to her answers to lawmakers’ questions about decisions that contributed to the disaster in Benghazi. But you needn’t be a Clinton sympathizer to believe that, given a choice, she would rather have gone before Congress already than to have gone through a health scare that threatened her greatest asset.

Linda P. Campbell is a columnist and editorial writer for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

Copyright 2013 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Don't Miss a Story

Sign up for our newsletter to receive daily news directly in your inbox.