fracking banner
shale well

« Shale Sheet Home

Ohio EPA official: Lupo dumped at least six times

Published: Tue, February 12, 2013 @ 12:00 a.m.

EPA: Lupo admits disposing brine, oil in storm drain six times

  OHIO EPA Update On D&L Situation

An Ohio EPA On Scene Coordinator gives more details on a recent discharge of fracking materials in Youngstown.

An Ohio EPA On Scene Coordinator gives more details on a recent discharge of fracking materials in Youngstown.



By David Skolnick



Ben W. Lupo, owner of D&L Energy and Hardrock Excavating, admitted he ordered employees to dump drilling waste into a city storm drain at least five times before being caught Jan. 31, an Ohio Environmental Protection Agency official said.

Each time, starting in September 2012, Lupo had workers empty two 21,000-gallon tanks of brine material and oil-based mud, Kurt Kollar, on-scene coordinator for the OEPA’s Division of Emergency and Remedial Response, said Monday.

That totals 252,000 gallons of waste dumped.

“That’s what he’s indicating,” Kollar said about what Lupo told him.

Kollar made the first public statements, during a Monday meeting with city officials and the media, about a pattern of dumping by Lupo. The meeting was called by Mayor Charles Sammarone.

The revelation was made public more than a week after an anonymous tip led state investigators to discover the Jan. 31 dumping.

The OEPA’s special investigation unit is reviewing the matter as a “potential criminal case,” Kollar said.

The U.S. EPA’s criminal-investigation division is also on site at the D&L/Hardrock location on Salt Springs Road, investigating Hardrock and Lupo.

Sammarone is calling for Lupo to be prosecuted and said the city could file criminal charges.

Cleanup, which could take another week or two, shows evidence of previous dumping, Kollar said.

“As [Lupo] put it, ‘I did it at night because I was doing the right thing. I didn’t want someone thinking I was doing the wrong thing and create an uproar,’” Kollar said.

But Lupo was improperly dumping brine, drilling waste and oil-based mud into the storm sewer, Kollar said.

The materials dumped don’t pose “an imminent threat,” but Kollar said, “You don’t want it in your creek.”

If you look at the water in the creek, it appears to be “crystal clean. If you stick your boot or throw a rock down in the sediment, a big pocket of oil comes up,” he said.

The early results of an ongoing criminal investigation had shown Lupo directed employees to dump a mix of oil and brine water down a storm drain at Hardrock’s headquarters at 2761 Salt Springs Road on Jan. 31.

It wasn’t until Kollar’s statements Monday that it was revealed Lupo admitted having done it at least five other times.

Asked if he could confirm that Lupo had admitted to dumping similar drilling wastes on at least six previous occasions at D&L headquarters, company spokesman Vince Bevacqua said it was the first he’s heard of Lupo’s discussion with regulators. He could not comment further on Monday.

“Thank goodness this is not an everyday occurrence,” said Kollar, who added dumping like this is “uncommon.”

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources gave D&L 45 days to get all of the drilling waste material off of its Salt Springs Road site, and the company is working nonstop to comply, Kollar said.

ODNR has permanently revoked operating permits of D&L and Hardrock, but not the other companies’ — as many as 20 — owned by Lupo at that same address.

Lupo was given 24 hours to request an informal hearing to present evidence against the revocation with the chief of ODNR’s Division of Oil and Gas Resources Management, Richard Simmers. The agency confirmed Friday that Lupo had made the request.

Kollar said ODNR has “issued basically a cease-and-desist order” to Lupo.

Sammarone criticized the state for permitting D&L, which has at least 120 violations at 32 injection and extraction wells in Ohio and Pennsylvania, to conduct business.

The dumping is near the site of D&L’s shuttered Northstar 1 injection well, which the ODNR linked to 13 earthquakes, the most serious of which occurred Dec. 31, 2011.

“It’s about time somebody in Columbus finally tells this guy, ‘You’re out of business,’” Sammarone said. “He seems to have a problem following the laws and the regulations for this type of business.”

The U.S. EPA said Monday that approximately 100,000 gallons of oil and water had been recovered from the ground, a nearby creek and the Mahoning River.

In an email, Francisco Aracute, agency spokesman, said most of what is being collected now is water.

He added that a warming trend over the weekend did not create problems for workers. Melting snow helped remove leftover debris and carry it downstream to containment booms.

The agency estimated that approximately 76 cubic yards of solid waste, including oil and other sediments, has been collected as well.

Contributor: Business writer Jamison Cocklin


1becky47(34 comments)posted 3 years, 5 months ago

Mr. Lupo obviously has a blatant disregard for the environment and the health of the residents not only of Youngstown but all who live along the Mahoning River. I am sure he would not dump this material in his own backyard but feels no remorse about doing it in ours. First his business practices caused damages with the earthquakes and now he is attacking our water ways. “I did it at night because I was doing the right thing. I didn’t want someone thinking I was doing the wrong thing and create an uproar” If you are doing the right thing you don’t hide under the cloak of darkness. He knew what he was doing was wrong and was hoping not to get caught. My concern is that first he admitted to 20,000+ gallons and now just a week later is stating it could be as much as 250,000 and not just once but up to 6 times. His well on Salt Springs was shut down a year ago and he waited till Sept to start dumping the overage. I DOUBT THAT.. I am concerned we will soon find out he has been dumping since the shut down. We need to shut this man down and file charges to the fullest extent of the law. I just feel bad for his employees that rely on him for paycheck, they do not deserve this.

Suggest removal:

2excel(1312 comments)posted 3 years, 5 months ago

Now if we could only ban the dumping of feces tainted sewer water into the river and go to composting toilets. Right now every flush contributes to polluting the river.

Suggest removal:

3HappyBob(360 comments)posted 3 years, 5 months ago

Prime example of why regulations are necessary. I've no doubt that Mr Lupo will be one that contends that government regulations are stifling business.
Without a doubt, there are many business persons that act responsibly and ethically, and it's a shame that they have to be burdened with regulatory paperwork.

Unfortunately there are those "bad apples" that spoil the business environment for all. All business operators should be outraged because these actions by the few bad boys impact how business is regulated.

Suggest removal:

4Starbuck(6 comments)posted 3 years, 5 months ago

Nice post, Becky47! It was everything I wanted to say. This guy must have a screw loose. If he didn't know what he was doing was wrong, he shouldn't be in this business. While I agree that we need to feel sorry for the employees, finally someone had the nerve to speak up. Kudos to the whistleblower!

Suggest removal:

5Metz10987(145 comments)posted 3 years, 5 months ago

And he is still not in jail/? That is the real crime here.

Suggest removal:

6djicey99(73 comments)posted 3 years, 5 months ago

This is just bad publicity for the City of Youngstown and the Valley that will only go to fuel people's belief that this Valley is just a black hole of vile scum, and corrupt Businessmen and Politicians. They will look upon the City of Youngstown, its businesses and its officials and say, "what a wretched hive of scum and villainy."

Suggest removal:

HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2016 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes