facebooktwitterRSS
- Advertisement -
  • Most Commentedmost commented up
  • Most Emailedmost emailed up
  • Popularmost popular up
- Advertisement -
 

« News Home

Frack protesters: Facts or farce?



Published: Sun, August 4, 2013 @ 12:00 a.m.

By Todd Franko (Contact)


It’s not often that you show up to a news event and find that you’re part of the news.

Don’t Frack Ohio staged a protest Monday in Warren with about 200 people from around the Valley and the state.

Spotted among the handful of signs was “We deceive; You believe.”

Above the words was, um, our logo.

“The Vindicator.”

A close look at the sign showed the original target of the sign was Fox News. You can see the faint colors of that logo under the printout of our logo.

But they chose to target the Vindy. To be clear, they had many targets. We were just one.

That was not the end of the surreality. A chant crawled out:

“Give us a fracking break, we don’t want another quake.

“Block the roads, shut the gates; we don’t want your toxic waste.

“Oil and gas, go back to Hell; we don’t want your injection well.

“Vindicator getting rich, by being oil industry’s b****.

“Vindicator spewing lies, because of oil industry ties.”

Wow ...

I guess, to hear it said aloud, “Vindicator” has a bit better cadence for the chant than “Fox News.” Our name vs. “Fox” in the world of protest chant -writing is like getting dealt ace-jack instead of four-seven.

But as for truth and reality, the sign and the chant are ridiculous to the level of insulting — like a four-seven.

Truth and reality are the Achilles heel of any protest effort, and ultimately cuts into any effort’s ability to court new believers. It’s not just a shame that the anti-frackers chose to take aim at us, it’s completely inaccurate.

First, I’d like to have all “that getting rich” stuff that they proclaim. Newspaper profits are tough to come by these days — in case you’ve not watched the Plain Dealer last week.

Second, “spewing lies” is a fairly pointed charge — and not absent of some harm and collateral effect.

I would say we are guilty of “spewing the complete story.”

And that’s what protesters of many issues often hate to hear — the complete story. Ignoring a complete story undermines one’s ability to be a complete contributor to society and articulate an issue.

Some protests lose even before they start because they swap facts for farce.

That’s the frack protesters’ problem.

But when they extend that personal misguidedness to actions that flat out call someone a liar and other unsurly things, now you’re affecting an honest workforce and economy.

Here’s the complete story of the Vindy and fracking to date:

We are very aware of the industry and have aggressively reported its arrival and expansion, no differently than we would the growth of U.S. 224 retail or Lordstown Cruzes.

That aggressive reporting sure has highlighted the promotion of many positives. It’s what a fair general media does.

But our work also has been tough on the industry.

I encourage you to look at yesterday’s story about aggressive landmen. In addition, look up these stories online:

April 28: Landowners face challenges over new leasing rules.

May 1: Proposal to transport frack waste on Ohio River.

July 7: Trumbull County gas and tempers flare.

Sept. 28: Disaster waiting to happen?

And all of this coverage is a backdrop to our award-winning coverage of the D&L earthquake issue. It was The Vindicator’s coverage — ridiculed by locals, state officials and even another veteran media person — that stoked the debate. When the big quake hit Dec. 31, 2011, state officials could not get on the phone quickly enough with our staff to explain what they now were going to do, even though they chided us for weeks.

The chiding of being too tough on the fracking industry even led to a spirited exchange between a current Vindy manager and a former one, who now helps promote the industry.

All of this amounts to:

Hate us for being balanced and complete.

But don’t chant “liars” and worse words when a complete look at the history shows the opposite.

It’s hurtful to the community and the merchants who have to decide every day if we are trustworthy.

Todd Franko is editor of The Vindicator. He likes emails about stories and our newspaper. Email him at tfranko@vindy.com. He blogs, too, on vindy.com. Tweet him, too, at @tfranko.


Comments

1questionreality(231 comments)posted 1 year ago

After reading this, a few quotes came to mind:

An Oakhill defense attorney once said: “The Vindicator’s claim that it represents the ‘public’ may be wishful thinking on its part, at best.”

“I would not be so foolish as to associate myself with a claim that Democrats are by nature dishonest, or Republicans inherently pure. Indeed, simply calling yourself a Republican does not make you honest anymore than calling yourself a journalist makes you objective.”

The bigger a man’s head gets, the easier it is to fill his shoes.

Suggest removal:

2ytownsteelman(627 comments)posted 1 year ago

Generally, liberals play fast and loose with the facts because their whole philosophy isn't based upon fact but emotion. This is why conservatives as so often frustrated, because rational fact based arguments have no effect on emotion based libs.

The anti frackers seemingly cannot even figure out the difference between a production well and an injection well, and cannot evaluate the availability, uses and limitations of various forms of energy. They try to make the case that fracking fluid that in itself is non toxic will somehow magically become toxic while being diluted in groundwater to poison that groundwater. I must have missed that lesson in science class.

Suggest removal:

3GeorgeinYoungstown(76 comments)posted 1 year ago

Doth Mr. Franko Protest too Much?

The reason why the Vindicators' coverage of the shale industry is being questioned isn't because the paper manages to publish an occasional espose' of the industry. There isn't a legitimately objective media outlet in existence that can ignore the negative impacts of this industry, since these impacts are growing by the day in shale communities around the country.

No, the reason the Vindy's coverage is being questioned is because of the stance the editorial board has taken - a clear and unambiguous and highly biased attack on the efforts of local citizens to restore local control over this industry, which, in many people's minds, is a de facto endorsement of the oil and gas industry. For every Vindicator article "critical" of the industry, there are 2 touting its economic "benefits." This may be "balance" to Mr. Franko, but when you wear the blinders one must wear to defend your employer, balance takes on a whole new meaning.

Mr. Franko's guarantees that the Vindicator's coverage has been "balanced and complete" notwithstanding, the paper's coverage is now tainted by its blatant disregard for objectivity in this case. It would have been better for the paper's editorial board to simply sit this one out instead of sticking their foot into the middle of it.

Also, the paper exposes its incredible level of hypocrisy and inconsistency when it promotes the citizens right to decide the ballot issues it thinks should be voted on, while attacking the one (The Community Bill of Rights) it thinks is unworthy, all the while wondering why the public would dare consider such conspiracy theories about undue oil and gas industry influence on such a "balanced and complete" paper!

TRANSLATION - "We support the democratic process, but only if you vote for the measures we want you to vote for!"

That's why their coverage of this issue cannot be trusted...they've placed the cloud above their heads and will now have to live with the level of mistrust they've brought opon themselves...

Suggest removal:

4kurtw(846 comments)posted 1 year ago

The 2nd Post- Ytownsteelman- says it: "Liberals play fast and loose with the facts because their whole philosophy isn't based on fact but emotion".

Amen Brother and Amen again! I couldn't agree more. You can never win an argument with a Liberal on any issue that concerns them because facts fly off them like water off a ducks back. It's blind faith all the way- a religion. Its like trying to ague with a Jehovah's Witness or a Snake Handler- after a while you realize- "Why am I wasting my breath- these people are impervious to reason".

Liberalism is a Religion. That's all there is to it. The only thing you can do is talk to the reasonable people on the sidelines and tell them the truth- hoping- and praying- that will be enough.

Suggest removal:

5kurtw(846 comments)posted 1 year ago

About Comment One: That's a bunch of baloney! The Vindicator doesn't "represent" the Public (nor does any media outlet)- the Public can take care of itself, thank you very much! All we need are the facts needed to make intelligent decisions. And, I think, the Vindicator, along with the other media outlets in the Valley, does a pretty decent job in that department. The rest is up to us.

P.S. The Bottom Line is there's enough objective information available for anyone who wants to reach an informed decision- to do so- the people who want to remain dumb (like the anti-frackers) will do so regardless.

Suggest removal:

6kurtw(846 comments)posted 1 year ago

The quote from Post # 3: "TAXATION IS THE REPATRIATION OF MONEY BACK TO THE PEOPLE".

Could someone please explain to me- possibly the writer herself- what the hell that means?

Taxes come from the people in the first place, don't they? And let's not forget the Revolution that kick-started this country hinged on that very issue: "Taxation without Representation...".

The above quote is pure, boiler-plate Marxism- take money from the greedy rich (large corporations and rich people in general) and give it back to the "people" from whom it was "stolen" in the first place (read Karl Marx- he wrote the Liberal Agenda strangling us now 140 years ago).

Only problem is, the money never gets back to the "people" at all- it goes to line the pockets of the Political Elite- 800 Billion in "stimulus" money- where did a high percentage of that money go? It went to cronies of the Obama Administration and other members of the Democrat Machine (the teacher's union got a huge chunk)- very little did anything to "stimulate" the economy at all- which, 5 years into "The Anointed Ones" watch is still moribund.

Our Constitution gives us- the people- the right to overthrow a government (as we did the British) if it becomes "tyrannical"- have we reached that point? Good question...

Suggest removal:


News
Opinion
Entertainment
Sports
Marketplace
Classifieds
Records
Discussions
Community
Help
Forms
Neighbors

HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2014 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes | Pittsburgh International Airport