- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

« News Home

GOP afraid of public employees

Published: Sun, May 20, 2012 @ 12:00 a.m.

By Bertram de Souza (Contact)

By one calculation, Ohio’s five public pension plans have unfunded liabilities of $66 billion. And yet, the Republican controlled General Assembly isn’t going to adopt an overhaul plan until after the November general election. Why? Because the GOP does not want to risk angering public employees the way it did last year with Senate Bill 5, the collective bargaining reform law.

The overwhelming rejection by Ohio voters in November of SB 5, which was pushed through by Gov. John Kasich and his allies in the Legislature, was a major political defeat for a party that had swept the statewide elections a year before.

The message from the state’s public employees and their Democratic Party supporters was powerful in its simplicity: Don’t mess with us.


That is why the legislation to prop up the four largest retirement funds won’t be enacted until after the Nov. 6 general election. Republicans don’t want to risk a backlash from the 300,000 public employees when there is so much at stake with the presidential election.

Ohio is a battleground state, which the presumptive GOP nominee Mitt Romney must carry in order to defeat President Barack Obama. No Republican has won the White House without winning Ohio.

Therefore, the state and national Republican party leaders are not only determined to bring out their followers, but are attempting to depress the Democratic Party vote. Hence, the effort to make it difficult for blacks, the elderly and the young to vote in November.

But even if action on the public pension rescue plan is postponed until after the general election — the Senate passed the measure last week, but the House won’t take it up any time soon — public employees should not be lulled into a false sense of security.

They should remember what Senate Bill 5 was about: stripping public workers of their collective bargaining rights.

Indeed, making Ohio a right to work state is GOP’s ultimate goal.

The decision by the House not to push for enactment of the pension reform bill clearly shows the extent of Republican hypocrisy.

The conservative think tank, The Buckeye Institute for Public Policy Solutions, issued a report last December titled, “Hanging By A Thread.” The study placed the total unfunded government pension liabilities at $66 billion.

“Ohio’s five defined-benefit public-pension systems are broken,” the study stated. “What began as a method of providing decent retirement benefits for public employees has evolved into a fiscal nightmare of red ink, runaway liabilities, and for many government workers, pension packages well north of $1,000,000. Ohio’s public employees and taxpayers deserve public-retirement systems that provide fair benefit levels to retirees at reasonable cost to taxpayers. Neither of those two principles is being fulfilled. Gold-plated pension packages and billions in unfunded liabilities is not what Ohioans bargained for.”

So, what should be done to make the systems financially stable?

The Buckeye Institute study noted there are two divergent paths Ohio legislators can follow when they deliberate the pension reform legislation. One aims at minor adjustments, such as increasing service-length requirements, retirement age, and Final Average Salary calculations.

No major changes

The study contends that while such measures will strengthen the pension funds temporarily, they won’t fundamentally change the structure of the defined-benefit system.

The other path is to move toward a defined-contribution-style retirement system.

“Like those found in the private sector, defined-contribution retirement systems place less risk on the backs of the taxpayers while allowing for significant cost savings,” the Buckeye Institute contended. Government workers would have to take on some risk, but under the current system they bear none. Taxpayers would be expected to cover the unfunded liabilities.

But that necessary discussion will not be held any time soon in the GOP-controlled General Assembly.

Indeed, after the defeat of SB5, Gov. Kasich argued there were aspects of the bill that have popular support among taxpayers in the private sector, but he has not weighed in on the pension reform legislation. It’s all about politics.


1chuck_carney(499 comments)posted 3 years, 2 months ago

State employee should get no better salary, retirement plan and other benefits than the average, six-pack joe worker. I can't continue to afford the increased growth of government and the burteaucracy.

State employess just don't understand us.

Suggest removal:

2DwightK(1378 comments)posted 3 years, 2 months ago

You know Chuck, the problem may be that too many people aspire to be average. Teachers, firefighters, police and corrections officers don't have average jobs. They deserve to know they have a decent pension at the end of their service.

If the average joe six pack doesn't like their job they are free to improve their skills and get another.

Suggest removal:

3chuck_carney(499 comments)posted 3 years, 2 months ago

Youngstownbornraised and Dwigtk, you just do't get it to paraphrase a now famous VP. I'm so happy that you probably back the 1% and the Wall St. fat cats.

i believe it's a question of fundamental fairness when viewed in light of the overburdened taxpayer aka the average joe six-pack who works at the factory all day long work low wages and benefits to feed his family. Obviously something you've never had to do since feeding from the public trough.

it's the same unfairness as the US Congress exempting themselves from Obamacare in order to avail themselves of blue chip health care which is not available to joe six-pack.

Notice I didn't resort to name calling. You start calling names when you have a weak argument

Suggest removal:


HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2015 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes