Staff and wire report
More earthquakes will occur despite the shutdown of the injection well on Ohio Works Drive in Youngstown, a seismologist investigating the quakes said Monday.
“The earthquakes will trickle on as a kind of a cascading process once you’ve caused them to occur,” said John Armbruster, a seismologist at Columbia University’s Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory in Palisades, N.Y.
“This one year of pumping is a pulse that has been pushed into the ground, and it’s going to be spreading out for at least a year,” he said Monday.
The well used to dispose of wastewater from oil and gas drilling almost certainly caused a series of 11 minor quakes in the Youngstown area since last spring, Armbruster said.
Research is continuing on the now-shuttered injection well at Youngstown and seismic activity, but it might take a year for the wastewater-related rumblings in the earth to dissipate, he said.
Brine wastewater dumped in wells comes from drilling operations, including the so-called fracking process to extract gas from underground shale that has been a source of concern among environmental groups and some property owners. Injection wells have also been suspected in quakes in Arkansas, Colorado and Oklahoma, Armbruster said.
Thousands of gallons of brine were injected daily into the Youngstown well that opened in 2010 until its owner, Northstar Disposal Services LLC, agreed Friday to stop injecting the waste into the earth as a precaution while authorities assessed any potential links to the quakes.
After the latest and largest quake Saturday at 4.0 magnitude, state officials announced their beliefs that injecting wastewater near a fault line had created enough pressure to cause seismic activity. They said four inactive wells within a five-mile radius of the Youngstown well would remain closed. But they also stressed that injection wells are different from drilling wells that employ fracking.
State Rep. Robert Hagan of Youngstown, D-60th, on Monday renewed his call for a moratorium on fracking and well injection disposal to allow a review of safety issues.
“If it’s safe, I want to do it,” he said in a telephone interview Monday. “If it’s not, I don’t want to be part and parcel to destruction of the environment and the fake promise of jobs.”
He said a moratorium “really is what we should be doing, mostly toward the injection wells, but we should be asking questions on drilling itself.”
State Rep. Sean O’Brien of Brookfield, D-65th, said he thinks a two-week moratorium on all injection wells in the area is more appropriate.
“I think we have a responsibility to act in the appropriate manner,” he said in an interview with The Vindicator Monday evening. “This is big business that’s coming to us, and we recognize that. ...We’ve got to slow down and make sure we’re doing it right.”
The quakes began last March with the most recent, on Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve, each occurring within 100 meters of the injection well. The epicenter of the New Year’s Eve day quake was on state Route 711 near the Mahoning River, in Youngstown, near the D&L injection well. It caused no serious injuries or property damage.
A spokesman for Gov. John Kasich, an outspoken supporter of the growing oil and natural gas industry in Ohio, said the shale industry shouldn’t be punished for a fracking byproduct.
“That would be the equivalent of shutting down the auto industry because a scrap tire dump caught fire somewhere,” said Kasich spokesman Rob Nichols.
He said 177 deep injection wells have operated without incident in Ohio for decades, and the Youngstown well was closed within 24 hours of a study detailing how close a Christmas Eve quake was to the well.
The industry-supported Ohio Oil and Gas Association said the rash of quakes was “a rare and isolated event that should not cast doubt about the effectiveness” of injection wells.
Such wells “have been used safely and reliably as a disposal method for wastewater from oil and gas operations in the U.S. since the 1930s,” the association’s executive vice president, Thomas E. Stewart, said in a statement Monday.
Environmentalists are critical of the hydraulic fracturing process, called fracking, which utilizes chemical-laced water and sand to blast deep into the ground to free the shale gas. Critics fear the process itself or the drilling liquid, which can contain carcinogens, could contaminate water supplies, either below ground, by spills, or in disposed wastewater.
Permits allowing hydraulic fracturing in Ohio’s portion of the Marcellus and the deeper Utica Shale formations rose from one in 2006 to at least 32 in 2011.