Vindicator Logo

Discrepancies run deep with Ohio well taxes


Monday, February 6, 2012

inline tease photo

By Chris Cotelesse

The NewsOutlet

As Ohio prepares to usher in a multibillion-dollar gas-drilling industry, the state relies on an honor system to collect taxes and fees from well owners — and the numbers don’t add up.

Well owners are required to report the amount of natural gas they “sever” from the earth and file severance-tax returns each quarter.

But an examination of production numbers by The NewsOutlet, a collaboration of journalism programs at Youngstown State, Kent State universities and the University of Akron, raises questions about their reliability, and no one has an explanation for the disparities in what represented a $2 million revenue stream in 2010.

From 2000 through 2009, the Ohio Oil and Gas Association, which represents the industry, reported more natural-gas production than did the Ohio Department of Natural Resources — the agency responsible for regulating wells.

The variations were wide, with ODNR’s annual production numbers 3 percent to 15 percent below those of the association.

In 2010, it was the opposite: ODNR reported more production than did the association.

An analysis of severance taxes collected by a third source — the Ohio Department of Taxation — suggests a third set of gas-production numbers, which means that two state government agencies have different numbers.

Tom Stewart, oil and gas association executive vice president, said he estimates production by examining “first-purchaser” figures, which represents the amount of natural gas bought at each well site.

“We try to zero in on what the best number is to report what the production is. I think we get it pretty close,” Stewart said.

State officials said they don’t have the authority to go to the wells and check the meters against the reports, and there is no explanation for why there are different numbers.

“We just process the tax returns and allocate the money to ODNR’s oil-and-gas program,” said Gary Gudmundson, spokesman for the taxation department.

ODNR said much the same.

“We don’t really evaluate them from the viewpoint of whether they’re true or false,” said Mike McCormac, oil and gas permitting manager for ODNR, speaking on the tax returns.

He said ODNR’s mandate is to collect the data and force well operators to comply, but the agency only recently has been given the authority to pursue action against delinquent production reports. Staffing and an overload of public-information requests is difficult for the newly established oil and gas division, he added.

Today the dollar amount represented by the discrepancies — perhaps $1.5 million over 10 years — is small relative to the state budget.

In 2010, the last full year for which information is available, the state collected $2.07 million from the gas-severance tax, compared with a state budget of more than $50 billion.

Production has been in decline. Twenty years ago when gas production was about twice the recent rate, the state received an inflation-adjusted $5.9 million a year.

But the oil-and-gas industry said it expects to drill nearly 4,000 wells in Ohio in the next four years.

Projections by the Ohio Oil and Gas Energy Education Program suggest that production in 2013 could be double that of 2010, and output will rise exponentially the following two years.

Using the education program estimates, the state could collect nearly $40 million in taxes and well fees in 2014 — if gas production is accurately reported and tax rates remain the same.

Ohio Policy Matters, a research and advocacy group in Cleveland, concluded in a study that Ohio could generate significant new revenue if it raised its tax rate to that of other gas-producing states.

The organization said while Ohio ranks 19th in the nation for natural-gas production, it ranks 25th among the 35 states that had severance taxes in 2010.

The organization said if Ohio raises its rate to match rates from other states, it could generate as much as $538 million in additional dollars through 2015.

Ohio Policy Matters encouraged the increase to improve oversight, handle environmental issues, and support the state’s general fund.

Currently, 90 percent of the severance tax goes into the oil- and gas-well fund for regulation of the mining and drilling industry, capping of abandoned wells and site cleanup if operators fail to do their job. The other 10 percent goes into the state geological mapping fund for mapping state resources.

Only when there is leftover money does it go to the state general fund for other purposes.

In 2010, the state added a 0.5-cent fee to the 2.5-cent tax on every thousand cubic feet produced — and similar fees to other types of extraction, including mining and oil production.

At that time, the Ohio Legislative Services Commission said the new fees would help with staffing. The Division of Mineral Resources Management said it had 35 full-time employees and planned to add about 33 for oversight.

ODNR admits that oversight already is a problem.

“Some days we can spend almost the whole day just on the phone or responding to emails. It’s a total balancing process to be responsive to the public and yet try to get statutory work done,” McCormac said. is a collaboration among the Youngstown State University journalism program, Kent State University, University of Akron and professional media outlets, including WYSU-FM Radio, The Vindicator, The Beacon Journal and Rubber City Radio (Akron).