- Advertisement -
  • Most Commentedmost commented up
  • Most Emailedmost emailed up
  • Popularmost popular up
- Advertisement -

« News Home

JOE SCALZO | A Solution to public-private problem?

Published: Wed, December 26, 2012 @ 12:08 a.m.

In 2007, Coldwater was the only team capable of beating a seemingly unbeatable Cardinal Mooney football team.

The Cavaliers’ athletic director may have an answer for an even tougher problem involving schools like Mooney’s.

Eric Goodwin, who has been the school’s AD since 1998, believes he has a simple solution to the public-private debate. Under Goodwin’s plan, any open enrollment student would count as 150 percent toward a school’s enrollment.

So, if Riverdale High has 100 students and 30 of them are open enrollment, 115 students would count toward the school’s total when the Ohio High School Athletic Association assigns divisions.

And if St. Riverdale has 100 students? Since it’s a private school, all the students would be open enrollment, giving them 150.

“I have never thought it was or should be a public vs. private debate,” said Goodwin. “I just believe the current situation needs to be monitored better. Some public schools are just as guilty as private schools in regards to bringing in players for athletic purposes.”

That’s why Goodwin believes the OHSAA should have harsher penalties for students who transfer during high school.

“For this to work, it should be simple: If a student enters any school their freshman year, that is where they stay,” he said. “If they go to another school at all, it is a one-year penalty.

“Exceptions should be few and far between. No apartments, no change of custody, no exceptions such as these. The only exception would be a physical move in which they no longer have ownership of the other property they were living in.”

Currently, athletes are eligible if they change residences, but as Goodwin hinted, there are too many ways around this rule. He believes students should change schools for academics only and believes coaches should lose their licenses if they’re caught cheating. He also thinks cheating schools should get a two-year ban from postseason tournaments for all sports.

While Goodwin’s plan is harsh, it’s not coming from someone whose school is incapable of competing with the state’s best. Over the last 12 years, Coldwater has played Mooney or Ursuline in the state finals five times. The Cavaliers won both meetings with Mooney (2005 and 2007) and lost all three meetings with Ursuline (2000, 2009 and 2010). They won this year’s Division V state football title and have won state titles in six other sports since 1990.

“Coldwater has taken pride in trying to compete against the Youngstown-area schools,” said Goodwin, whose school has had just one open enrollment student on its football team during his tenure. “Obviously we have had mixed success against both of them, but we do take pride in being able to try to compete with them.

“With separate tournaments, we would have never had the great state final game of 2007 of Mooney vs. Coldwater.”

The past two years, Ohio’s principals have voted down complicated referendums that took into account things like student lunches, tradition and boundaries. In May, those principals will decide whether or not to separate tournaments between public and private.

I think Goodwin’s solution is a better option.

Joe Scalzo is a sports writer for The Vindi cator. Write to him at scalzo@vindy.com.


1busyman(239 comments)posted 3 years, 7 months ago

Here is a simple solution without creating 2 seperate playoffs. When a private school in a lower divison plays a higer division school and beats them, do not give them the higher points of that divison and all the teams points of the team that beat other higher division schools. Reduce the number of points to the lesser. This way a school such as we have here in the valley that is 6 and 5 but beat 3 division 1 schools would not have the computer points to make it into the playoffs. Just a thought

Suggest removal:

2valleyred(1103 comments)posted 3 years, 7 months ago

Busy, that has got to be one of the stupidest ideas I've read regarding the public-private debate in quite some time. What on earth does that solve!?


Suggest removal:

3YtownSports(306 comments)posted 3 years, 7 months ago

Goodwin's solution is a good one. Probably makes too much sense. to be adopted.

Suggest removal:

4busyman(239 comments)posted 3 years, 7 months ago

For years teams like Money and Ursuline play Fitch, Boardman and Warren Harding, beating them and earning div 1 points for the computer rankings. These higher Div 1 points have helped these schools make the playoffs with records of 5 and 6 or 6 and 5 and then play through their division like butter most of the time. It is all about computer points. At least this would let the inter area competition take place. If they seperate, you will not see these great match ups again. With the idea of the open enrollment ratio, the public schools still miss out on the cream of the crop of all around student athelete when it comes to what school and program they are attracted school. It is just another thought. If it goes the other way then Money and Ursuline and the others will play a lot of games on the road.

Suggest removal:

5Zebrajoe50(1 comment)posted 3 years, 7 months ago

Simple solution, since some private schools can't help but recruit the best athletes from their area public schools make them play two divisions above in which the school would be normally participating in. I feel it is an injustice to young men who have for example have been in a private elementary feeder school and has had to participate in such things as First Communion and Confirmation. I feel that athletes who have not participated in these programs should have to before they become eligible to play for these schools. My reason for this is because it is not just about being an athlete at these schools it's about being a student of the system and participate in all aspects of the institution. I feel if these young men would make school eligible to at within their division when they participate in programs missed at their elementary feeder schools.

Suggest removal:


HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2016 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes