facebooktwitterRSS
- Advertisement -
  • Most Commentedmost commented up
  • Most Emailedmost emailed up
  • Popularmost popular up
- Advertisement -
 

« News Home

Deep cuts in funding strain Ohio care facilities



Published: Sun, December 2, 2012 @ 12:01 a.m.

SEE ALSO: • Residents get a voice in inspection of state’s 956 nursing homes

• Code violations lack full context, nursing-home worker argues

• Nursing home residents struggle with a $40 allowance per month

AN IN-DEPTH LOOK AT OHIO’S NURSING HOMES

By CAITLIN COOK and CHRIS KOCHERA

TheNewsOutlet.org

Download as PDF:
Valley Renaissance hearing

Discharge hearing from Valley Renaissance Healthcare Center

Download as PDF:
Harrington nursing home 2005-2010

Nursing Facilities, Staffing, Residents and Facility Deficiencies, 2005 Through 2010

Download as PDF:
Budget Projection of OHP Medical Services - SFY 2010

Budget Projection of OHP Medical Services - SFY 2010

Download as PDF:
Budget Projection of OHP Medical Services - SFY 2011

Budget Projection of OHP Medical Services - SFY 2011

Download as PDF:
Budget Projection of OHP Medical Services - SFY 2012

Budget Projection of OHP Medical Services - SFY 2012

Download as PDF:
Budget Projection of OHP Medical Services - SFY 2013

Budget Projection of OHP Medical Services - SFY 2013

As a child, Sam Berresford visited a former neighbor in a nursing home. “People were yelling, strapped in chairs, and it smelt like urine. It was a scary place,” he said. “I was scared to death.”

The experience inspired Berresford to consider a career in nursing, but decided to become an administrator instead. Now he is in charge of Cortland Healthcare Center in Cortland.

“I love my job,” he said. However, his job and those of other administrators are getting harder now that the 956 nursing homes in Ohio are getting less money from Medicaid and Medicare.

House Bill 153 was implemented in July 2011, the beginning of the state fiscal year. It rebalanced funding for long-term care by cutting Medicaid rates paid to nursing homes by about 6 percent.

It was one of the largest budget cuts in recent years.

Then in October 2011, Medicare cut funding by an average of 11 percent nationally, claiming it had underestimated the cost of changes made in skilled nursing facilities the year before. Some Ohio facilities faced cuts of up to 12 percent.

These two major cuts within six months proved challenging for many facilities, said Peter Van Runkle, executive director for the Ohio Health Care Association, which represents 750 long-term and special care facilities in Ohio.

“Our members have been doing their best to provide quality care, but it’s been very difficult to do that,” he said. “It created a lot of stress.”

The Numbers Tell The Story

Once the Great Recession of 2008 hit, it wasn’t just consumers who had to tighten their belts. Losses in revenue affected states and the federal government as well, which is why reimbursement rates for nursing homes were reduced.

Analysis of flash reports of Ohio budgets shows that in fiscal year 2010, the state spent 11 percent of its $24.14 billion budget on nursing homes. By fiscal year 2012, when the state budget was at $26.39 billion, the percentage dropped to 10 percent, with a savings of $234 million.

According to the Governor’s Office of Health Transformation, Medicaid reimbursements for nursing homes has decreased more than 5.8 percent in the past year. The average daily reimbursement per patient was $176.27 in 2010, with the rate falling to $167.25 in 2012.

The U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services list 78,221 residents in 956 Ohio nursing homes. Most of these residents are on Medicaid.

The majority of nursing home funding comes from the state’s disbursement of the Medicaid program, which accounted for 21 percent of the state’s medical services budget in fiscal year 2010 and dropped to 16 percent in 2012.

Nursing homes receive money from several sources. According to the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, nursing homes in the nation receive 42.9 percent of their money from Medicaid, 19.8 percent from Medicare, 24 percent out of pocket and the remaining 13.3 percent from private health insurance and other private funds.

The new Ohio bill also implemented funding changes that were outlined in House Bill 66. That bill, enacted in 2005, changed how Medicaid paid for long-term care. The state shifted from a cost-based payment system to a price-based system. In essence, the state opted to not reimburse nursing homes for what they paid for supplies and services, but what they should have paid for them.

Also, the state is promoting home and community based care as an alternative to institutional care.

Quality was also addressed. Under HB 153, nursing homes that meet five of 20 quality measures will not face funding cuts by the state, said Van Runkle. These measures are grouped in five categories: performance, choice, clinical, environment and staffing.

How Homes Handled The Cuts

Faced with cuts in reimbursements, local nursing home administrators had to choose how to meet the challenge of reducing spending.

One way was staffing.

“When they cut the funding, they cut the staffing ratio as well,” Berresford said.

To absorb a funding cut of $100,000 in 2011, Cortland cut department head positions and delegated that work to other staff members such as registered nurses, certified nursing assistants and state-tested nurses aides.

“So my residents didn’t feel a change, they never noticed that we got thousands upon thousands cut,” he said. “They still get the same care, they get the same food – everything, nothing changed for them.”

Other facilities also anticipated the state budget cuts. Vista Care Centers, formerly Briarfield, operates four skilled nursing facilities and two independent living facilities in Mahoning, Trumbull and Columbiana counties.

“As a company, we have always been fiscally responsible,” said Tracy D’Andrea, chief operations officer of Vista Care Centers.

“We predicted when the budget cuts would occur. It was actually an opportunity, more so than a challenge, to be better.”

Vista Care changed staffing levels by evaluating hours when residents needed the least amount of care and reduced staffing during those hours.

“We looked at those hours and made adjustments that way,” D’Andrea said. “It did not affect the quality of care.”

Vista Care also looked into other ways to cut costs, such as group purchasing. This allows several facilities to group together and buy items in bulk.

Adequate Staffing Levels Hard to Determine

While state budget cuts aimed to curb Medicaid spending and boost quality measures, they can also affect staffing levels, which some experts say is paramount to quality care.

“It’s all about staffing and as a country, as a state, in the government we don’t have a commitment to make sure these homes have adequate staffing, we can’t expect the care to get better,” said Charlene Harrington, a registered nurse and professor emeritus at University of California at San Francisco where she studies staffing, funding and quality of care in the nation’s long-term care system.

In her 30 years in the business, Harrington has not seen a significant growth in quality care or staffing levels.

“The staffing levels are starting to increase a little, but they’re still completely inadequate. That’s why we have so many horrible quality problems all across the country,” Harrington said.

Harrington and other researchers say staffing levels, which include all certified and support staff, should be at 4.1 hours for each resident per day. Ohio averages 3 hours and 58 minutes per residents, according to Medicare.gov.

Cortland Healthcare averages one aide for every 12 residents, and one registered nurse and one licensed practical nurse for every 25 residents.

Harrington said a nursing assistant shouldn’t have more than six or seven patients.

She also believes Medicare’s five-star rating system is helping to increase staffing levels. Medicare using this system at it’s “Nursing Home Compare” website to rate nursing homes in several categories: overall, health inspections, quality and staffing. People looking at homes for a loved one may be less inclined to consider a facility with a one-star rating.

However, the biggest problem is the state and federal governments don’t have a guideline for optimal staffing.

“Federal law requires all nursing homes to provide enough staff to adequately care for residents,” states the Medicare website. “However, there is no current federal standard for the best nursing home staffing levels.”

The federal government does require nursing homes to have at least one registered nurse on duty for “at least eight straight hours a day, seven days a week.” Also, there must be a licensed nurse on duty 24 hours a day.

The site also warns users that the staffing levels are reported by the nursing homes and Medicare has no way to verify the accuracy of those numbers.

In Ohio, nursing facilities can skirt staffing issues without facing financial penalties simply by meeting one of the other 20 quality measures identified by the state. As long as facilities meet five of the 20, they won’t face reimbursement reductions.

Harrington said states can enact legislation to increase staffing levels, but many rarely will.

“The reason the states don’t want to increase the staffing is because then they have to spend more on the Medicaid rates.”

A $30 million budget bill that would have given nursing homes more money, providing that they adhered to quality measures, won approval in the Ohio House and Senate in April and May, respectively. However, Kasich vetoed the bill in June, saying that no new information had been presented to justify the specific amount requested.

“We would beg to differ on that,” said Van Runkle. “We will continue to support additional funding for meeting quality measures, as well some other adjustments to the reimbursement formula and other policy items not directly related to Medicaid rates.”

As Berresford said, facilities won’t have a hard time finding people to do the work, but they will have a hard time compensating them adequately for their work.

TheNewsOutlet.org is a collaborative effort between the Youngstown State University journalism program, Kent State University, The University of Akron and professional media outlets including, WYSU-FM Radio and The Vindicator (Youngstown), The Beacon Journal and Rubber City Radio (Akron).


Comments

1timOthy(802 comments)posted 1 year, 4 months ago

Kasich has a Rainy Day Chest full of money ! But the REPULICAN EMPOR will release it for his AGENDAS ! While people are doing without in Privately owned Nursing Homes ! This makes NO SENSE AT ALL !

Two years this fool will be gone. But people will do without and DIE While America Preaches equalizes and equality of life. As it DOES NOTHING AT HOME. In America.

Can some explain to me why it's okay to let these humans do without ?? But abortion is totally WRONG. Both produce Death Republicans ! Which bring me to the conclusion that Republican are Champions of THE DEATH SQUADES !

Suggest removal:

2retiredfella(31 comments)posted 1 year, 4 months ago

We have no money for the citizens, maybe the politicians need their pay cut in half with a loss of benefits. I am tired of the theft by our politicians for their own pockets!!

Suggest removal:

3isaac45(258 comments)posted 1 year, 4 months ago

well, these people are the takers, so they get what they deserve...get a job losers

Suggest removal:

4Ypboy(50 comments)posted 1 year, 4 months ago

Obamacare at work. You stupid Dems voted for this. Thanks.

Suggest removal:

5Education_Voter(816 comments)posted 1 year, 4 months ago

There are different types of facilities.

There are facilities that care mostly for patients who have Medicare and Medicaide only and who operate on a shoestring.

There are facilities that toss patients out when they run out of their own assets, and where the owners of the facility live lavish life styles, some of the wealthiest people in the Valley. And yet in their facilities, far before Obamacare, most employees are part-time and working for another facility part time as well. The staff is stretched thin, and family must get in there daily to help.
For people without children.....it's bleak.
And yet, the employees of these places, the nursing aides, the cooks, they are angels doing God's work and getting little or no notice.

Suggest removal:

6metroman(40 comments)posted 1 year, 4 months ago

You can always pay for your parents care with the money they saved. Oh, you want a new house. I forgot. Did you sell your mothers house before the three year period kicked in? Have you every thought about taking care of your love one yourself? Everyone wants to run to the government for help. I don't have a problem helping people that need the help but playing the system isn't going to work anymore.

Do you think the State prints the money? It does not fall from the sky, it comes from tax payers. Ohio State Constitution requires the budget to be balanced. To bad the good old USA does not have the same requirement.

Fifty million on food stamps, 1/2 the people paying no income tax, college loans for people that can't get a job and when they get out owing $100K and can even file bankrupts on it. FEMA on Sandy; that's an example of government at work. Their answer; put the displaced in a closed prison! We will all be in prison if we don't wake up.

Suggest removal:

7fd6636(254 comments)posted 1 year, 4 months ago

yep!! Kasichcare!! States LOADED with "rainy day" funding, and our seniors will suffer. How can some of you dolts out there blame demos when the govenor is Republiturd? This is the Republican slashing! Remember: Some of those who are for this will end up in these seniors shoes one day. And by the way, Rainy day funds mean Kasich special agenda funding, Remember when our gov. said even with SB5 , and serious cuts, we still would not get our state out of debt for years? Who's lying now!!!

Suggest removal:


News
Opinion
Entertainment
Sports
Marketplace
Classifieds
Records
Discussions
Community
Help
Forms
Neighbors

HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2014 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes | Pittsburgh International Airport