Washington must fix our broken health care system
EDITOR:
I am writing to ask that our federal legislators and President Obama work diligently to fix our broken health care system, and find workable solutions to meet the needs of American families and businesses. The organization in which I work employs 75 full-time employees and 165 part-time employees. I am very aware of the exorbitant cost associated with providing health care to our full time employees which constitutes only a fraction of our work force. Over the last four years, the cost of our health care has increased over 38 percent with decreasing benefits and increasing employee contributions for co-pays, deductibles and premiums. Unfortunately, we are unable to provide insurance for our entire workforce and the many of our staff are included in the 46 million Americans that are uninsured.
Most of those that are uninsured as well as underinsured do not have the financial resources to pay co-pays for preventative care. Therefore, many allow their medical conditions go untreated which eventually results in time lost from work, which speeds up the vicious downward spiral medically as well as financially. In fact, I understand that half of all personal bankruptcies stem from medical expenses. This is not good for our neighbors, community, employers or our country.
I hope that our legislators will work to ensure that quality, affordable health care is available for every American; that we can eliminate co-pays for preventative care (as in “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure”) and that we end coverage denials for pre-existing conditions. Healthy communities lead to healthy work forces and healthy economies.
JOSEPH F. CARUSO
Austintown
Some of the talk about fixing health care is scary stuff
EDITOR:
I’m a 28-year-old mother of three kids. What I have heard on the news about these brilliant health care plans is dumb. Other countries have done the whole government control thing, and, guess what, it doesn’t work. They come to us for help. If it hasn’t worked elsewhere, chances are its not going to work here. Wow, I didn’t graduate from college, and I figured that out.
I do not want government controlling my health care or controlling the doctors. If you’re healthy and fine, then this plan would work. But if you’re not, you’re screwed. What do I do then for my parents who are getting older and my children? Oh, sorry, honey, we can’t fight your cancer because John Doe says we can’t use that medicine or can’t afford it.
We should improve our health care, but not so it hurts people in the long run. Health insurance should be there for people, but people do have to pay for it. It’s not fair for me to pay so others can have it, and when I need it I can’t get help because what I’m going through costs too much.
If you or your kids were sick, you would want the best treatment and doctors — not a stranger telling you how things should be working.
HEATHER JOKI
North Jackson
Motorist saved by a wave
EDITOR:
Last Saturday, my husband was at the corner of Indianola Ave. and Hillman St. heading north on Hillman at the traffic light which was green for him. In the northeast corner suddenly a man jumped up waving his arms. My husband stopped in time to avoid a car speeding west through the intersection at speed which he estimated at 70 mph.
If he hadn’t stopped I’m afraid to think what might have happened. I hope the man in the purple shirt who waved him a warning will see this letter and know that he is thanked sincerely for his thoughtful act.
PATRICIA MARSHALL
Youngstown
Bernie deserves better than he got — in life and in story
EDITOR:
I feel compelled to comment on The Vindicator’s recent story concerning one of our Valley’s favorite son’s, Bernie Kosar. I attended one of our local parochial schools with Bernie for eight years. Even as a young boy, he stood out. He was not only a straight-A student, but a kind and polite boy who we all looked up to as the leader of our class. He possessed something you don’t see very often in children that age — a drive and determination that obviously brought him great success in life until his most recent troubles.
Let’s not forget that success in reaction to The Vindicator’s unflattering story that portrayed Bernie as an eccentric, physically deteriorated, ex-NFL quarterback. When I read that he grew up to be a generous, giving man who willingly gave away large amounts of money, I was not surprised.
I hope that he is able to find the inner strength to overcome all of the challenges he is currently facing and wish him the best.
SUZANNE FISHER GREENAWAY
Youngstown
Facts show we’re not the best
EDITOR:
The health care discussion needs to be conducted in light of facts, not opinion, fears, and bias.
There are many who say that the United States has the best health care system in the world, and that claim is used to support the position that we should not reform or change an already world class system. Unfortunately the data that is available seems to deny these most patriotic claims of “best in the world.”
While it is true that the United States leads the world in health care spending and that the United States is ranked first in responsiveness to its citizens demands, its overall health care performance is 37th. I was shocked to learn that the United States trails Japan, Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Columbia, United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, Costa Rica and many others.
BOB ELSTON
New Middletown
Great news, but a bad picture
EDITOR:
What great news for our wonderful city to rank in the Top 10 for business potential in the nation. We are finally beginning to be recognized outside our community for the greatness we possess.
However, to my dismay, as I turned the pages of Entrepreneur magazine one thing was most obvious to me. Every town featured had a full page article with a photo of the city across the top of each page. Each photo showed the city at its best ... evening, with all the city lights. Then there was Youngstown, the only daylight shot, with a view of the back of the City Hall Annex as one drives down the Market Street Bridge.
Of all the beautiful “photo-ops” around town, why would the photographer choose this particular shot to highlight our city?? One has to wonder.
PHYLLIS A. RICCHIUTI
Poland
Comments
Yeah, too bad the CBO just gave a blow to the argument that the government can actually save money with this stupid program.
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/...
This crazy socialist healthcare push is sending Obama's approval rating down the tube.
This is in regards to Heather Joki's letter. Anyone who believes that there is not a bureaucrat already inextricably involved in a doctor's decisions regarding a patient's care must be blessed with rediculously wonderful group health insurance. In fact, I've had that "wonderful" kind of health insurance and decisions were still made by doctors with insurance plans on the brain.
Secondly, here's an article for the argument that universal coverage "doesn't work":
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Americans get the poorest health care and yet pay the most compared to five other rich countries, according to a report released on Tuesday.
Germany, Britain, Australia and Canada all provide better care for less money, the Commonwealth Fund report found.
"The U.S. health care system ranks last compared with five other nations on measures of quality, access, efficiency, equity, and outcomes," the non-profit group which studies health care issues said in a statement.
(...)
Per capita health spending in the United States in 2004 was $6,102, twice that of Germany, which spent $3,005. Canada spent $3,165, New Zealand $2,083 and Australia $2,876, while Britain spent $2,546 per person.
Entire article here:
[www.reuters.com]
Again, this is for Heather Joki and those who feel / think as she does:
Today's Fresh Air program on NPR interview with Maggie Mahar.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/st...
Assuming the above info is accurate, I sure hope that Britain is spending less than us, because they are denying care for stage 4 breast cancer. Even despite that, the NHS is going bankrupt in 2 years.
I sure hope Canada is spending less than us, because due to long waits for all things medical, many Canadians ignore their health issues or go to the USA. Physician shortages are exacerbated by government rationing of physician incomes.
In Canada, limited colonoscopies have led to a 25% higher rate of colon cancer and a ban on the use of the two best chemotherapies are part of the reason why 42% of Canadians with colon cancer die while 31% of Americans, who have access to these two medications, survive the disease.
Overall, the death rate from cancer in Canada is 16% higher than in the United States and the heart disease mortality rate is 6% above ours’.
This is no game. Wise up fast. Government-run health care has a 100% failure rate. Politicians should not be deciding who is to live and who is to die.
Nonsocialist, I swear you've said that before but of course of all us that believe in small government and freedom seem to be beating a dead horse. I guess some people just won't ever get that government is the problem, not the solution.
S4A,
And I'll keep saying it. And I'll keep calling my legislators. The bus is headed for the cliff at full speed, and we're trying to tell the driver where to find the brake, or at least how to take the foot off the gas. Stunningly, many on the bus don't care or are excited about the "change" the cliff will bring. They sit in their seats chanting, "Yes, we can!"
It all depends on 2010, my friend, 2010.
I believe that all these other countries spend less per person on health care than we do in the US. But as usually is the case, you get what you pay for. Personally I want the best and the brightest to be doctors. I want care WHEN I need it, not months (or in some cases years) later. I want my elderly parents to have medical care, not end-of-life counseling. I've asked before....has anyone read this bill or do you all just want "free health care". Ask the Europeans and Canadians about their health care. They will tell you about rationed care and month long waits to see doctors.
But in the U.S., people are not getting the best. People are denied health care all the time. They can't get the prescriptions they need, or they don't qualify for a new treatment, or they have a pre-existing condition and can't get coverage at all. My family was paying $250 a month out of pocket for health care, and still had to pay 20% of all our bills, plus co-pays every doctor visit and prescription. In the course of a year, we paid close to $5,000 in health care costs, and didn't even have anything major happen.
Meanwhile, insurance companies are raking in profits. While I'm not 100% sold on any of the proposed solutions, we do have a system in crisis. Decisions need to be made with people's health in mind, not the bottom line.
No doubt the health care system needs reform. Personally, I favor Tort reform and free market solutions rather than a model proven to fail (HR 3200).
You're gonna pay for your health care with HR 3200. They are considering taxing your health benefits, taxes on foods and beverages they (Big Brother) feels you shouldn't have. The conservative estimate by the CBO for HR 3200 is $1,000,000,000,000.00 over 10 years. Oh yeah, you're gonna pay..and you may not like the denials and delays in care, or the quality of the care. Class warfare tax policies will at best cover 1/3 of the new mandate. BTW, when the government sticks it to my employer (the "wealthy"), I end up paying.