Another side of Gaza’s story
EDITOR
I would like to comment on a July 28 column, “Visit to Gaza was an eye opener.” This is a report about a humanitarian mission of 200 “patriots” who went to Gaza to “deliver badly needed medical supplies from America to this besieged population of 1.5 million humans inhumanely trapped within a closed ghetto for the past 2 years”. The article blames Israel of committing “the greatest atrocity of our times”.
One cannot but wonder how did the Gazans survive this terrible siege for 2 years before they were “saved” by these “patriots”? How come there was never one case of starvation or hospital closing during these 2 long years?
The truth, of course, is that every day around a hundred trucks are crossing the border from Israel to Gaza delivering food, medicine and humanitarian aid to the UN agency in Gaza, which then distributes it all across Gaza. The “siege” of Gaza is intended only to prevent smuggling bombing material into Gaza and suicide bombers from Gaza into Israel. Before the siege, terror was raining on Israel from Gaza.
A case in point is Wafa al-Bis, a young Gazan woman who sustained severe burns from a cooking accident. She required sophisticated reconstructive surgery that was unavailable in Gaza, so Israel granted her free surgery in Israel on a humanitarian base. On her last visit, on June 20, 2005, she was stopped by Israeli security guards who found her loaded with explosives. This was going to be her expression of gratitude to the Israeli hospital and the medical staff who saved her.
The “patriots” material assistance to Gaza was less then a drop in the bucket compared to the daily Israeli assistance to Gaza. It is, however, a pity that this patriotic humanitarian mission missed the only human being in Gaza that really needed their intervention the most: the kidnapped Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit, who has been in solitary confinement in Gaza for three years. The Gaza regime has denied him any human rights. The international Red Cross was prevented from visiting him even once, despite numerous requests. His mother, who did not hear from him for three years, was denied even a picture of him, despite her repeated pleas to the cruel rulers of Gaza.
The article ends with quoting the immortal words from the Declaration of Independence about the inalienable rights of all men, and wishing these rights for Gaza. It is a bit of a stretch that the people of Gaza, who were overjoyed and danced in the streets on 9/11, and who celebrated every suicide bombing on busses and in coffee places in Israel, the same people who denied their innocent victims the right to life, have the audacity to expect the right to freedom and the pursuit of happiness for themselves. Even hypocrisy should have a bit of decency.
A. Z. RABINOWITZ
Liberty
What about us?
EDITOR:
I am very angry that our own law makers that we put in office don’t care if we have health care. They have wonderful care and the heck with everyone else.
If we don’t get some kind of health care reform, I will not vote for anyone who doesn’t support this bill. Congressmen should think about us and not the money they are getting from big health-care companies.
BONNIE MARVIN
Youngstown
Comments
A.Z., I think that you had better search your heart and soul and maybe you'll see why the Palestinian people feel like second class citizens. When an entire ethnicity of people have been put down for so long, there are bound to be strong emotional feelings. In your letter you use the words, "It is a bit of a stretch that the people of Gaza, who were overjoyed and danced in the streets on 9/11, and who celebrated every suicide bombing on busses and in coffee places in Israel, the same people who denied their innocent victims the right to life, have the audacity to expect the right to freedom and the pursuit of happiness for themselves. Even hypocrisy should have a bit of decency."
Right there you have stated what is in your heart and soul that you feel that ALL Palestinians have the AUDACITY TO EXPECT THE RIGHT TO FREEDOM AND THE PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS FOR THEMSELVES. What a terrible way to feel. I truly believe that you need to search your soul. You are referring to little Palestinian children, and actual human beings who have been living in an oppressed situation for many years and you feel that they DO NOT HAVE THE RIGHT TO FREEDOM AND THE PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS. Let us not forget how slavery, the Japanese concentration camps, genocide and the Jewish concentration camps have been a blight on our entire global soul and now the Palestinians. You said it in your own words that the Palestinian people do not have the right to happiness or freedom. SHAME ON YOU. I will pray for you.
I agree, there have been wrongs committed by both the Israelis and the Palestininians in this conflict but your statement makes my soul sad to hear such attrocious words coming from a human being in regard to other human souls. This conflict needs to be resolved for all humanity and your feelings do nothing in that regard- just the same as some horrible Palestinian groups feel that Israel doesn't have the right to exist, you too obviously feel the same way about the Palestinians. THere lies the problem, the Israeli's aren't perfect and blameless in this conflict and neither are the Palestinians. But hardline opinions such as yours do nothing to resolve this conflict.
I am not Palestinian nor am I an Israeli, I am an American of Irish ethnicity and I often think of how our entire country would react if we were told that we were stripped of our citizenship and were made refugees because the religion of the Native American Indians demanded that this land was deemed theirs based on their religion. THere would be quite an uproar and much protesting, fighting, etc. Just food for thought.
maybe you should check your facts: these so called oppressed people have tripled their population since being in so called captivity. you don't know what you are talking about kellie , cause if you had the correct historical facts you would realize these people carried Jordanian passports up until 1969, when they realized they could create a fake movement and rip off governments around the world for years taking money for their "cause" they created a fake name for suckers like you to help their cause. get a life and the so called palestinains need to go back home to jordan
backatyou,
I am going to have to disagree with you, in regards to my post, I do have my facts correct. I am greatly saddened to see two people so full of hate for others. Everyone in this world has the right to HOPE for freedom and happiness. I find it a sad state of affairs when people disagree over such a fundamental right. Both Israelis and Palestinians deserve a two state solution and the right to live without fear from each other. You can hold grudges forever but that doesn't solve the present state of affairs. Also you apparently didn't even consider my post as it really expressed emotion regarding A.Z.'s statement that a group of people shouldn't have the right to happiness or freedom. I'm not quite certain what "facts" you are referring to.
Raed Khatid and Werner Lange are ready, willing and able to address/debate this issue and share photos of their Gaza mission with anyone interested.
How do you begin to refute an article which is essentially a string of lies? I am a proud Palestinian-American whose parents were forced in fear for their lives by armed Zionist thugs from their homes near what is now the Ben Gurion Airport (Lid/Lod) into Gaza in 1948. I just returned from Gaza less than three weeks ago. I can tell you from first-hand experience and internationally documented facts, not Zionist propaganda, that the situation in Gaza is dire. The 100 trucks a day to which Mr. Rabinowitz refers represent far less than the bare minimum needed for the 1.6 million people living and dying in Gaza. If it wasn't for the tunnels from Egypt, many more people would die. The Palestinian Gazans do not need Israel or their Egyptian collaborators. All these people need is for the pirates of the Israeli Navy to stop interfering with Gaza's coastline and its access to international waters. If Gaza could control its own waters and (air space for that matter) it could freely import and export to the rest of the world and turn itself into another Hong Kong. Unfortunately, that is exactly what the powers that are now choking Gaza want to avoid.
The siege is illegal,unjustified and inhuman. It must end now.