- Advertisement -
  • Most Commentedmost commented up
  • Most Emailedmost emailed up
  • Popularmost popular up
- Advertisement -

« News Home

Obama will be a tough sell in Ohio

Published: Sun, August 31, 2008 @ 12:00 a.m.

By Bertram de Souza (Contact)

By Bertram de Souza

As this is being written, Democratic vice presidential nominee Joe Biden is on national television ripping into his “good friend” John McCain, the presumptive Republican nominee for president. It’s an impressive performance by the veteran U.S. senator from Delaware, and the Democratic Party faithful packed into the Pepsi Center in Denver are relishing the red meat.

But as Biden ticks off the reasons a McCain presidency would be a continuation of President Bush’s eight-year tenure, this question comes to mind: Will Biden’s impressive r sum , especially his foreign policy credentials, help Obama in the battleground states that the senator from Illinois lost in the primary to Hillary Clinton?

More specifically, will an Obama-Biden ticket be able to turn red Ohio blue?

That question would not be so compelling today had New York Sen. Clinton been the vice presidential pick. Her performance in the March 4 primary in the Buckeye State, in which she beat Obama handily, and her huge base of support in predominantly Democratic regions like the Mahoning Valley would have changed the dynamics of the race.

As it it now, the contest is a virtual dead heat, according to a recent Quinnipiac University poll. Forty-four percent of the respondents favored Obama, while 43 percent said they were for McCain, who will accept his party’s nomination this week at the Republican National Convention in Minneapolis-St. Paul.

Buffo performance

It had to have been a “V8” political moment for the Democratic nominee last Tuesday night when he saw the jammed convention center in Denver literally rocking as Clinton stood at the lectern, and as he listened to the reaction of the party faithful when she spoke. It was a buffo performance by the most talented female politician in America today. Just ask her husband, former President Bill Clinton, who also wowed the crowd when he addressed them Wednesday night.

Obama must have had to restrain himself from slamming his hand against his forehead and quipping, “I should have had her on my ticket.”

Why he didn’t will remain the most intriguing question of this presidential election.

Not only would Clinton have brought the 18 million voters who supported her in the primary election to the table, but she also would have made it so easy for people like Ohio Gov. Ted Strickland and other statewide Democratic officeholders who supported her to embrace the Democratic ticket.

Hillary Clinton’s support among blue-collar workers in Ohio, among hard-core Democrats and even among black voters parallels that of Bill Clinton’s.

As has been noted in this space on several occasions, Obama’s being black is a major hurdle in this state. Indeed, the willingness of labor leaders in Ohio and around the country to finally address the issue of race publicly last week is a recognition that while Obama has done very well with blacks, the young and the college educated, older white women still vote in larger numbers than any other group. And, they are the ones need to become comfortable with a black in the White House.

Historic moment

This is not to diminish the historic event that occurred in Denver when Obama stood as the first black to be nominated for president by a major political party. But there is nothing to suggest that the warm and fuzzies evident Thursday night when Obama addressed about 80,000 party faithful in Mile High Stadium will translate into enough votes in November to win.

Indeed, if Ohio is the key battleground state, as some political experts suggest, given that President Bush’s reelection four years ago was due to his winning here, then the Democrats have an uphill battle.

Obama will be a tough sell in this state, even with Biden on the ticket. The senator from Delaware was born in Scranton, Pa., and came from a blue-collar family. His working-class pedigree does make him an attractive figure in regions like the Mahoning Valley.

But, Biden isn’t Hillary Clinton.

During the 1992 presidential election, Bill and Hillary and Al and Tipper Gore came to the Mahoning Valley and drew 10,000 people to the Southern Park Mall parking lot.

Long-time Democrats compare that appearance to John F, Kennedy’s in downtown Youngstown.


1valleyred(1103 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

You guys saw Palin last night. You liberals think every speech you gave would attract the swing vote, we'll you're wrong. Last night's speech will connect with MIDDLE AMERICA!


Suggest removal:

2cambridge(4132 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

The Republicans had their chance for eight years and the results speak for themselves. McCain's policies are the same as Bush. I do agree that Obama wont carry Ohio. People in Ohio didn't get it four years ago, I doubt the get it now.

Suggest removal:

3ytownoptimist(86 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

Don't underestimate the youth vote, the African-American vote, the female vote (I don't believe every woman can identify with Palin and who the hell plays hockey in the Midwest anyway?) and then all the other Democratic voters. I don't think Ohio is a total wash at all. To think that we can predict this election is laughable. Anything could happen the night before the election that may sway the vote one way or another. I don't think Palin necessarily connected with all of Middle America. 1) you are assuming that all of Middle America even watched her speech. 2) you are assuming that no one in Middle America is the least bit Democratic leaning.

Suggest removal:

4Ytown_born_and_bred(27 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

I agree ytownoptimist. And as the column stated, it may be a hurdle for him to carry the state because of his race, but what confuses me is, if this same group, "the young and the college educated, older white women still vote in larger numbers than any other group. And, they are the ones need to become comfortable with a black in the White House," were the ones that loved Hillary are willing to vote for McCain, because of race, then who cares about the economy, healthcare, or any issues that we are facing, they want 4 more years of the same majority being failed policies, and an unclear future for themselves and their children, etc. It's sad, but not totally unbelievable that we still cannot overcome race. And I cannot wait for the debates, that way we can see what Palin is about, because if McCain doesn't live to the end of his term, God help America if she becomes President. Ohio didn't get it right 4 years ago, but maybe 8 years of problems will knock some sense into the voters.

Suggest removal:

5andersonathan(687 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

Obama might have a problem carrying any state and Palin has more executive experience and is better prepared to be number one that Obama who is running for number one. If you want a change in Ohio and Youngstown then you and me need to take charge and start with local county and state officials. this is how the systems works. no president is going to come to Youngstown and go here rebuild, grow, prosper. it does not happen that way. Money comes down from the federal government and has to applied for and every one applies. This is why city councils, mayors and governors are here to find and try to provide for the people. Your voice to Washington should be viewed through your congressmen.

Palin has experience at all levels "DA" it is her responsibility to control and use resources to protect over 6000 miles of unsecured coast line with Russia 120 miles away? she has worked with Japan, China, Russia, Spain and others over international fishing rights, international waters. Seafood is the no 1 GNP of Alaska timber and oil and gas follow. In a global war Alaska is a Major target this why we have all parts of the military and massive bases there. Our ports are a major concern there. She has cut spending. cut taxes. Took money from silly things and has raised Alaskans in port, export, jobs and productivity seems like that is what we are looking for?
Or do you want something else? expand you thoughts and mind we are not the center attraction of the USA, steel is not coming back to this area So why don't we find another way to get us on the map again? GM nope. Delphi nope. Why don't we become the solar capital of the world? Building and manufacturing our part and products and putting Youngstown Ohio on the stamp it just a thought, or a brain fart depending.

Suggest removal:

6ytownoptimist(86 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

Excuse me but women care about their individual rights over their own bodies and having their children educated regarding birth control to avoid STD's and AIDS than any positives Palin might represent. Palin would be so right wing with the appointment of Supreme Court justices that it is downright scary (I do realize that congress approves the justice but the prez does have a lot of power in this). Look at what Bush has done with the Attorney General's office and with appointing idealogical judges. Palin would be a worse alternative. She might not care about the environment or protecting it for future generations but the women of America do care. It is a woman's right to have control over her own body and being pro-choice isn't all about wanting people to make a very difficult decision about keeping a pregnancy. Its about wanting people to be educated before it gets to that point.

Suggest removal:

7dmets(575 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

All i know is Ohio has lost more jobs in the past 8 years under a republican ran government. They promised more jobs to our area as more and more were lost. I don't see how anyone can not be sick of it and see that McCain is 4 more years of Bush. All they care about is Ohio's vote then they kick us to the curb like trash. They see people in Ohio as muppet and them the puppet master. I didn't vote for Bush fearing exactly what has happen to Ohio and America. I just see is getting worse with McCain. We need a change, one that will take a look at the people of Ohio and America, and see we need a good leader who will get us back on track!

Obama Biden for a BETTER future for OHIO and AMERICA!!

Suggest removal:

8andersonathan(687 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

Some one is right it is a women's body and "her choice" and I can't help she is Pro-Life, The same bill obama supported on abortion allows aborted babies to be killed if they survive and late term abortions many illnesses and sickness can not be detected until late in to it. So i guess the messiah has become God? I just believe like many people life begins at conception. So if people and evidently obama wants to select and crate a race it is up to them but at least I will know who is behind it. I have never voted [r] on a president it will be a first i want a strong conservative in high office.

Ohio was run by Taft for eight years and people answered to it.

NAFTA a republican idea and Clinton put it into action and it did not destroy america in fact it elevated areas in this country. It also raised Ohio's gross productivity, i can't help it they did not build the factories in Youngstown area.

You have a mayor trying to push wall mart around? "DA"

Age is a easy target i always found those who shoot at easy targets don't have many arrows.

Supreme court who knows you just might get change there also.

And Palin she is in charge of the country's largest wild life reserves and parks.

maybe if the Dems would take off 5 weeks and go on vacations we could get a energy plan in action?

Suggest removal:

9talkinghead(9 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

@ ytownoptimist: I know it's hard for some to believe, but abortion rights isn't the most important issue for all women. It's important to the majority of woman, but I don't think many live in fear that the law as it exists will change much.

Some democratic leaning women will move to McCain's side partially because of Palin and partially because McCain isn't a party line Republican.

To believe this move won't help him and that (unfortunately) racism won't play a part in this election is to live in denial.

My prediction is that McCain wins by about 3% nationwide and a slim electoral margin...

Suggest removal:

10MillCreeked(24 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

While I agree that there are issues that concern this election more than reproductive choice, I would caution Talkinghead about the statement that people don't live in fear that the law will be changed. The majority of Americans are pro-choice, plain and simple. McCain/Palin will appoint judges to overthrow Roe v. Wade. That is unacceptable to most Americans and thus it is a serious part of the election. If Roe v. Wade is overturned, abortions will continue to happen at the same rate, but many adult women will die from complications like they do in third world countries. How is that saving "lives"?

As for AndersonNathan, perhaps invading countries without just cause and thus allowing soldiers and civilians to die or be disabled for life for no reason is less important to you than the potential for life contained in a unborn fetus, but it seems to me to be a gross imbalance of morality on your part to vote for a party that continues to lead innocent adult Americans to their deaths for no reason just so you can feel better about than controlling the reproductive rights of women. If you cherish life so much, go out and demand and end to this facade of a war we've been waging on...who?

Suggest removal:

11cambridge(4132 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

When McCain made his acceptance speech he stated that "the Republicans were in charge and they lost their way." He admitted they had their 8 years and screwed up.

For the last 8 years he voted with Bush 90% of the time. His policies are exactly what Bush has done for the last 8 years. But if you give him a chance and vote Republican again he will change everything that went wrong. He helped it go wrong.

I have to say it again. If you vote for McBush you just don't get it.

Suggest removal:

12ytownoptimist(86 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

Believe it or not, not all Americans believe in creationism but do believe in science. This is another area that Palin has extremely right wing viewpoints. So, let's say they can't get another Scalia or Thomas on the Supreme Court, they will still appoint other levels of judges who chip away at Roe v. Wade via allowing picketing at Planned Parenthoods (which actually do give birth control to women who cannot speak to their parents about sex - I knew many women in college who had evangelical parents that would never support taking them to a gynocologist for birth control) and the like.
Yes, women and mothers care about the economy but they also care about choice. McSame doesn't have any refreshing ideas regarding the economy. Its more tax breaks to the corporations "hoping" they will trickle down to the worker. Hmm, I seem to remember Reagan's trickle down theory didn't work either . . .

Suggest removal:

13330treehugger(3 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

DeSouza is right: Hillary on the ticket might have locked Ohio up for the Dems. Florida and Michigan likewise have disgruntled democrats who are resentful of the failure to count their votes in the primary. All three states will be an uphill battle for Obama.

If only one in ten angry Hillary voters and one in ten white Dems votes for McCain-Palin it more than throws the election to the Republicans.

Suggest removal:

14andersonathan(687 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

hello, again hey millcreekent i never supported the Iraq war in fact i would have just bombed them them till it is a sand castle. i am very open to that, a ground war is not what we need. i do how ever support our troops so if they are there then we have to fight. it took America a long time and hard fought battles to get and stay were we are at. yes it is a republican war machine headed by or was by people like Rumsfeld, Cheney, and Bush not my favorite people neither was Bush SR. How did fell to let the CIA run it for four years? it is a war of favors and oil in Iraq, blood for oil. Anything that involved 9/11 was pure political and un American if you voted or spoke out on it. It was called political suicide.
Do i want our tax dollars going there [no] do i want our gasoline money going over there [no] do i want the troops there [no] but just to pack up and leave is not right then you telling all the dead, wounded, crippled soldiers and there family's and loved ones what thanks! But the war was wrong sorry. it is amazing how that area wants the beloved BHO in office. I cant vote for some one who walks around issues like he does he avoids confrontation on them changes the subject. Hierarchy when she debated his usually won the next primary. The man wants the roll of people and voice and change to sweep over the lack of non-meat in what he is feeding you in Illinois senate a present vote is equivalent to a no vote. making June 10Th a holiday and a special day for the white sox is not what i am looking for in leadership. Ayre's, Wright Flagger move-on, Oprah, Time Warner, Soreus. i don't need that either.

Suggest removal:

15cambridge(4132 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

What Muslim is running for president?

Suggest removal:

16ytownoptimist(86 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

1) Obama is a declared Christian. 2) Muslims are citizens of the United States, too. Do some research on worldwide religions and you will see what % of Muslims are actual terrorists. FYI: few religions don't have violence in their historical background. Have you ever heard of the Crusades . . .?

Now, let's get back to the actual topic at hand. Who is the better individual to represent all of America in this melting pot of a country and who will make us proud in the global front and restore pride to our name around the world.

Suggest removal:

17talkinghead(9 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

@ ytownoptimist:

I'll give you that Scalia is a dyed in the wool conservative. However, He, Thomas and Roberts are above anything, strict constitutionalists. They aren't activist judges that read things into the constitution that aren't there.

As far as picketing Planned Parenthood: how can you argue a citizens right to protest? Just as anyone is allowed to protest a given church, business or organization. Even the NRA and anyone that enjoys the freedom we have in this county should support that right.

Saying that "Believe it or not, not all Americans believe in creationism but do believe in science." smacks of elitism and assumes that all conservatives dismiss evolution. There are differing factions within both parties.

I raise this question: If the democrates don't win now when can they? Bush has made some terrible mistakes and given the left an open door. Can they stumble through it?

Suggest removal:

18dmets(575 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

Tomcat like Palin's Bible thumping religon is a good thing? The woman stated that the war in Iraq is "God's will"!

Oh and Obama is not Muslim either and here is a repport for you Tomcat. If you are going to state things, at least make them truthful facts! So here is you proof he is NOT muslim:
Obama sets record straight on his religion
Presidential candidate battles misconception that he's a Muslim

updated 10:49 a.m. ET, Mon., Jan. 21, 2008
COLUMBIA, S.C. - Barack Obama is stepping up his effort to correct the misconception that he's a Muslim now that the presidential campaign has hit the Bible Belt.

At a rally to kick off a weeklong campaign for the South Carolina primary, Obama tried to set the record straight from an attack circulating widely on the Internet that is designed to play into prejudices against Muslims and fears of terrorism.

"I've been to the same church _ the same Christian church _ for almost 20 years," Obama said, stressing the word Christian and drawing cheers from the faithful in reply. "I was sworn in with my hand on the family Bible. Whenever I'm in the United States Senate, I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. So if you get some silly e-mail ... send it back to whoever sent it and tell them this is all crazy. Educate."

One piece features photos of Obama praying with the words "COMMITTED CHRISTIAN" in large letters across the middle. It says Obama will be a president "guided by his Christian faith" and includes a quote from him saying, "I believe in the power of prayer."

A second piece, which like the first doesn't mention the Muslim rumor, includes photos of Obama with his family and a caption that says they are active members of Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago. It explains how as a young man Obama "felt a beckoning of the spirit and accepted Jesus Christ into his life."

So Tomcat you can see he is NOT muslim!

Obama Biden 2008 for a BETTER AMERICA!!!

Suggest removal:

19talkinghead(9 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

Please site a credible source where Palin states that the Iraqi war is "God's Will." MoveOn.org does not count BTW.

Also, it's silly to state that Obama is a Muslim. That's just trolling. Ignore it.

Honestly, haven't we moved beyond religiously based attacks?

Suggest removal:

20baxter(1 comment)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

here it is, from the horse's mouth:


Suggest removal:

21andersonathan(687 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

obama campaign [most media] has experience in distracting everyone from what the should be looking at, he is a empty suit , a player running for president, the election is what 2 months from now? and they can't remember what he said 3 months ago the truth is coming and it will set you free.

they kicked Clinton around like a used soccer ball, doing the same to Plain by the time the debates and town meetings are over McCain/Palin will cover Ohio by 15%

Obama has voted [imagine that] against bills to help American farmers bills affecting big and small farmers. In the end rural farm land America will stand up. "VIVO MCCAIN" "VIVO PALIN"

Suggest removal:

22dmets(575 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

Thank you baxter!

Suggest removal:

23msell716(9 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

I was for Clinton; Obama was too arrogant to choose her for
a v.p. so my vote goes to McCain-Palin. I have confidence in
McCain that he is qualified and is separated from Bush; I have confidence that Palin can be a President. If George Bush can become President, anyone can!

Suggest removal:

24ytownoptimist(86 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

msell716 - I have to ask if you were a Hillary supporter then what policies that she stood for do you see McCain supporting? I'm sorry but Sen. Clinton was my senator in New York state when I lived there. I know her background and policies very well. I find it hard to believe you truly are a Hillary supporter if you can switch over to McCain so easily. Their viewpoints on healthcare, choice, economic stimulation, Iraq (the list goes on and on) are opposite. And Palin is even more opposite Sen. Clinton than McCain. I find it baffling. Hmm, are you just saying you're a Clinton supporter to make it look like Clinton supporters are now McCain supporters?

Suggest removal:

25lucy(135 comments)posted 7 years, 10 months ago

Way to go Ytown. I think most Hillary Clinton supporters have already figured out that Sarah Palin is nowhere near Hillary Clinton, either in substance or in style (meaning behavior, not clothing).

As for Obama's VP pick, it's clear that he chose a running mate who he felt would compliment his qualifications...the intelligent, not arrogant, way to run a campaign.

Suggest removal:


HomeTerms of UsePrivacy StatementAdvertiseStaff DirectoryHelp
© 2016 Vindy.com. All rights reserved. A service of The Vindicator.
107 Vindicator Square. Youngstown, OH 44503

Phone Main: 330.747.1471 • Interactive Advertising: 330.740.2955 • Classified Advertising: 330.746.6565
Sponsored Links: Vindy Wheels | Vindy Jobs | Vindy Homes