HOW YOU SEE IT
Would you give?
The Vindicator asked 100 of its News Contacts what reasons would keep them from donating their organs, or those of a family member:
My only reticence about organ donation would be if it was found out they were being sold to the highest bidder rather than donated to those individuals with the greatest immediate need or those with the best chance of long-term viability. Other than those reservations, it's a selfless act that gives you a chance to be a hero to someone in need, and in doing so, enriching not only their life, but the legacy of the one you lived.
I have carried a donation card for many years and have thought with joy that I might give sight to someone who needs it.
One of the primary reasons that could keep me from donating my organs is not knowing exactly what they will be used for. Will the organ go for a needed transplant, or will it end up on the cutting floor of a medical school?
CINCINNATI, FORMERLY OF YOUNGSTOWN
Nothing would keep me from donating mine or my family's organs. It's the right thing to do.
WEST MIDDLESEX, PA.
If I were allowed to choose the recipient, I would probably decline a candidate that didn't meet my criteria for an upstanding human being. However, when the organs are placed in an organ bank, you don't have that choice, properly so. The small chance that somebody unsatisfactory to me might receive the organ would not deter me from donating the organs. It is a terrible waste to destroy organs that are needed by others.
I was asked recently by the DMV and declined. I believe that in the future I would consider it. People's views tend to change as we age.
STEPHEN L. MORRIS
AURORA, ILL., FORMERLY OF YOUNGSTOWN
With all the unfortunate people out there on waiting lists for organs, it seems such a waste to not do so. People that are uncomfortable making this donation of life should reconsider.
JOHN A. BRABANT
The only reason that would keep me from donating organs of my family members is if they didn't want to be part of organ donation. I, myself, will be an organ donor when the time comes.
Organ donation has always been of importance to me. A close family member died a month ago without ever receiving a much-needed liver. Had there been more willing people to donate their organs, he may be alive today.
It would depend on what shape I was in when I no longer needed any of my parts. For family members, pretty much the same thing, or if the family member had expressed a preference. I would consider myself bound by that.
FOREST HILLS, N.Y., FORMERLY OF YOUNGSTOWN
I don't have a problem at all donating organs. If mine can help someone else live longer, I'm all for it.
If you have an e-mail address and would like to become a Vindicator News Contact, let us know.
We'll periodically send e-mails asking our contacts for their thoughts. The topic might be an issue we plan to address in the future or news events as they occur.
To become a contact, please type "Contact" into the subject line and send us your e-mail address, name, the town where you live and a daytime telephone number for verification purposes to email@example.com.